Receiving or issuing a disciplinary warning: employment lawyer in Munich
A disciplinary warning (Abmahnung) objects to misconduct and warns of consequences for the employment relationship. I review warnings for employees and executives and advise employers on preparing and wording them.
Key points
- A disciplinary warning describes a breach of duty and points to possible consequences for the continuation of the employment relationship.
- A dismissal for conduct is generally preceded by a warning (Section 1(2) KSchG; compare Section 314(2) BGB).
- An unjustified warning may have to be removed from the personnel file according to case law.
- The law sets no rigid period after which a warning loses its effect; it depends on the individual case.
What to do now
- Check the contentWhich incident is named, with what date, which allegations and which consequences?
- Do not accept anything hastilyCheck first, then sign or reply.
- Secure your documentsEmployment contract, warning, emails, notes and names of possible witnesses.
- Initial assessmentClarify together whether and how you should respond.
What I check in a warning
Content and specificity
A warning describes the incident specifically, objects to the breach of duty and points to the consequences. Blanket accusations are unlikely to be sufficient as a rule.
When a warning can be challenged
Incorrect facts, an incorrect legal assessment, disproportionality or lack of specificity can support removal from the personnel file.
Warning and dismissal
For breaches of duty, a dismissal generally requires a prior warning. Where the Dismissal Protection Act applies, a dismissal is measured against Section 1(2) KSchG.
For employers
Specific facts, factual wording, provability and proportionality: I review drafts and support you if a dismissal is in prospect.
Executives
If a separation is in prospect, warnings can affect your negotiating position and your later reference. Special rules apply to members of corporate bodies.
Costs
The introductory call helps clarify your situation and the possible scope of work. It does not include a document review. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. Whether legal expenses insurance covers the costs is something we clarify at the outset.
Your contact: Noah Osuji
Rechtsanwalt (German lawyer) in Munich, admitted to the Munich Bar Association (Rechtsanwaltskammer München). Advice in English and German.
More about meFrequently asked questions
Can I challenge a disciplinary warning?
Yes. You can challenge an unjustified warning and demand its removal from your personnel file. That may be possible where the warning contains incorrect facts, rests on an incorrect legal assessment, is disproportionate or is not sufficiently specific. A valid warning must describe the incident specifically, object to the breach of duty and point out the possible consequences for the continuation of the employment relationship; blanket accusations are unlikely to be sufficient as a rule. Do not accept the allegations hastily, and secure your employment contract, the warning, emails, notes and the names of possible witnesses. I usually begin with an out-of-court demand to the employer; whether a court action makes sense depends on the individual case. A counter-statement (Gegendarstellung) for the personnel file may be an alternative. Whether you should respond straight away is a question of strategy: according to the case law of the Federal Labour Court (BAG), you generally do not lose the right to dispute the accuracy of the warning in later dismissal protection proceedings, even if you do not take action against it at first. As at November 2026.
How long does a disciplinary warning stay in the personnel file?
There is no fixed period after which a warning must be removed from the personnel file; the seriousness and circumstances of the case are decisive. The employer may have a legitimate interest in keeping a record. A warning that was rightly issued generally does not have to be removed as long as the conduct has not become entirely irrelevant to the employment relationship (Federal Labour Court (BAG), judgment of 19 July 2012 – 2 AZR 782/11). This is separate from the warning function: even a warning that is still in the file can lose weight over time for a later dismissal. The law sets no rigid period for this either; the two years often cited are not a fixed rule. An unjustified warning, for example one based on incorrect facts or a disproportionate allegation, may by contrast have to be removed according to case law. Whether you have a right to removal in your case, I assess on the basis of the incident, the time elapsed and your later conduct. As at November 2026.
Is a disciplinary warning enough for a dismissal?
Not automatically: a warning can support a dismissal for conduct only if a further breach of duty of the same kind follows. For breaches of duty, a dismissal generally requires a prior warning (Section 1(2) of the Dismissal Protection Act (KSchG); compare Section 314(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB)). If a comparable breach then occurs, the employer may dismiss for conduct; whether the dismissal would be valid still depends on all the circumstances, in particular proportionality and a balancing of interests. Where the Dismissal Protection Act applies, that is, generally in establishments with more than ten employees and after six months of employment, the dismissal is measured against Section 1(2) KSchG. If there is a works council, it must be consulted beforehand (Section 102(1) of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG)). A claim against a dismissal generally must be filed within three weeks (Section 4 KSchG). If the underlying warning is unjustified, that too can make the dismissal open to challenge. As at November 2026.
Must the employer always issue a warning before dismissing?
No, not in every case: for particularly serious breaches of duty, or where a change in conduct cannot be expected, a warning may be unnecessary (compare Section 314(2) BGB). As a rule, however, a dismissal for conduct is preceded by a warning, because the dismissal must be proportionate (Section 1(2) KSchG). The warning is meant to show the employee which conduct is objected to and that the continuation of the employment relationship is at risk if it is repeated. It may be unnecessary, for example, where trust is so seriously damaged that the employer cannot reasonably be expected to accept even a first occurrence. Anyone considering a summary dismissal (fristlose Kündigung) must also observe the two-week period running from knowledge of the relevant facts (Section 626(2) BGB). Employers should therefore secure the facts, document the evidence and consider before deciding whether a warning is sufficient. I assess this on the basis of your facts. As at November 2026.
What must a warning issued by the employer contain?
A warning must contain three elements: a specific description of the incident, an objection to the breach of duty and a reference to the possible consequences for the continuation of the employment relationship. The incident should be described precisely enough, by time, place and conduct, for the employee to see what is alleged; blanket accusations are unlikely to be sufficient as a rule. The wording should remain factual, and every allegation should be provable, for example through emails, time records or witnesses. If a warning combines several allegations and one of them is wrong, the whole warning may be open to challenge. You should also check proportionality: not every minor breach justifies a warning. Finally, delivery must be provable; registered post by letterbox delivery (Einwurf-Einschreiben) is not sufficient for this in every case. I review drafts and support you if a dismissal is later in prospect. As at November 2026.
Arrange an initial assessment
Received or planning a disciplinary warning? By phone, in English and German.
Request an introductory callGeneral information, as at 14 November 2026. It does not replace advice on your individual case.