Dismissal and legal protection
Working time fraud: when can it justify dismissal?
Deliberately incorrect time recording can be a serious breach of duty. The label “working time fraud”, however, does not automatically lead to summary dismissal. Ambiguities, errors, questions of evidence, fault and less severe measures must be examined separately.

What conduct is actually alleged?
The term working time fraud is used for very different situations: invented working hours, breaks deliberately not recorded, an incorrect clock-in, or a dispute over whether a particular activity was working time. These situations must not be treated alike without examination. An incorrect booking is not yet proof of deliberate deception.
Even when working from home, being temporarily unreachable does not by itself prove that no work was done. Conversely, duties to record time correctly and to perform work do not lapse because the work takes place outside the workplace.
Why intent and clear rules matter
Deliberate manipulation can seriously damage trust. First, however, it must be established what rules existed, how the recording system works and whether culpable conduct can be proven against the employee. Unclear instructions, technical problems and prompt corrections can be relevant to the assessment.
The employment law allegation also does not automatically mean that all the requirements of criminal fraud are met. The legal standards and the necessary facts must be assessed separately.
Disciplinary warning or summary dismissal?
The Federal Labour Court treats deliberate breaches of time-recording duties as potentially serious breaches of duty. In its judgment of 9 June 2011 (2 AZR 381/10), it dealt with a summary dismissal and the weighing of interests. It does not follow from this that there is a rigid rule that employment must end after a certain number of minutes.
In a specific decision, relevant factors include scope, frequency, fault, damage to trust, the previous course of the employment relationship and the prospects of success of a disciplinary warning. For a summary dismissal, it must be unreasonable to continue the employment until the notice period expires.
What data and technical logs can prove
Time recording, access system and IT log do not necessarily answer the same question. Entering the building is not always the start of work; an inactive screen is not necessarily a break from work. The evidential value must fit the specific tasks. Data protection, co-determination and whether the respective information can be used as evidence must also be examined separately.
How to prepare for a hearing
- Note the specific day, period and booking process named.
- Have the rules on breaks, work-related travel, working from home and corrections ready.
- Secure your own lawfully available evidence and any technical errors.
- Do not alter documents afterwards or hastily sign blanket declarations.
Employees should have an allegation clarified objectively. Employers should openly distinguish between proven conduct, suspicion and a mere data discrepancy. After receipt of a written dismissal, the three-week period must in principle be observed.
Works council member: expenses and unrecorded breaks
On 24 February 2026, the Munich Regional Labour Court declined, in proceedings 6 TaBV 44/25, to replace the works council’s consent to a summary dismissal. The allegations concerned meal allowances and interruptions at meetings that had been recorded as working time. According to the official press release, a breach of duty regarding the disputed break times had not been sufficiently set out. In particular, the employer had not shown a sound basis for treating the interruptions as serving rest purposes only. (Official press release)
In the assessment of the expense claim, the factors weighed were a breach of duty, its weight, the employee’s open approach and the possibility of a disciplinary warning. The decision does not confirm a general right to claim every coffee break as working time. The applicable rules and the actual use of the time remain decisive.
For a works council member, the special consent procedure under section 103 BetrVG must also be observed. Exclusion from the works council is subject to its own requirements. The assessment of a breach of contractual duties under the employment contract and of a breach of duties of office must therefore not be equated. When published, the press release described the decision as not yet final; a later final status is not claimed here. (Section 103 BetrVG)
Legal bases and sources
- BAG, 9 June 2011 – 2 AZR 381/10
- Section 626 BGB – Summary dismissal
- Section 87 BetrVG – Co-determination
- Section 4 KSchG – Time limit for bringing a claim
Legal status and source check: 7 November 2026. General information; the evaluation of a specific case requires the complete documentation.
In addition: Have a disciplinary warning reviewed.
For advice on your situation: Employment law advice in English.
