Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Employment reference review and correction in Munich

Your reference accompanies every job application. I check whether content, wording and assessment are consistent, and I press for corrections. I help employers to draft references objectively and in line with the legal requirements.

Key points

  • When the employment relationship ends, you are entitled to a written reference (Section 109(1) sentence 1 GewO).
  • On request it also covers performance and conduct (qualified reference, Section 109(1) sentence 3 GewO).
  • The reference must be clear and comprehensible and must not contain hidden messages (Section 109(2) GewO).
  • Anyone who wants a grade better than “satisfactory” regularly needs facts in support.

What to do now

  1. Read the referenceGo through the statements on duties, duration, performance, conduct and closing line.
  2. Gather evidenceTarget agreements, appraisals, praise and projects that show your performance.
  3. Formulate changesSpecific wording proposals rather than general criticism.
  4. Initial assessmentClarify together what is realistically achievable.

What I check in a reference

Form and content

A simple reference states the nature and duration of the work. A qualified reference also assesses performance and conduct.

  • simple reference
  • qualified reference
  • Section 109 GewO

Assessment of performance

In practice “zur vollen Zufriedenheit” (“to our full satisfaction”) corresponds to the grade “satisfactory”. A “good” generally requires additions such as “stets” or “immer” (“always”).

  • performance assessment
  • conduct assessment

Hidden messages

Wording that is meant to say more than its literal meaning is not permitted. I read the reference for ambiguities and conspicuous gaps.

  • clarity
  • ambiguity

Executives and separation

In a termination agreement, the grade, the wording or an agreed draft reference can be settled as well.

For employers

Truth, clarity and benevolence within the bounds of truth: I review draft references and agree wording when a change is requested.

Costs

The introductory call helps clarify your situation and the possible scope of work. A document review is not part of it. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. Whether legal expenses insurance covers the costs is something we clarify at the start.

Your contact: Noah Osuji

Rechtsanwalt (German lawyer) in Munich, admitted to the Munich Bar Association (Rechtsanwaltskammer München). Advice in English and German.

More about me

Frequently asked questions

Am I entitled to an employment reference?

Yes. When the employment relationship ends, you are entitled to a written reference (Section 109(1) sentence 1 of the Trade Regulation Code, Gewerbeordnung, GewO). A simple reference (einfaches Zeugnis) states at least the nature and duration of the work. On request it must also cover performance and conduct; this is called a qualified reference (qualifiziertes Zeugnis, Section 109(1) sentence 3 GewO). In practice most employees ask for the qualified reference because it is expected in job applications. The reference must be clear and comprehensible and must not contain hidden messages (Section 109(2) GewO). Since 2025 it can also be issued in electronic form with the employee’s consent (Section 109(3) GewO). Where the separation is by termination agreement (Aufhebungsvertrag) or settlement, the grade, the wording, the closing line or an agreed draft reference can already be settled at the same time. Keep target agreements, appraisals and praise to hand if you later want a better assessment. As at: November 2026.

What does “zur vollen Zufriedenheit” (“to our full satisfaction”) mean?

In practice, “zur vollen Zufriedenheit” generally corresponds to the grade “satisfactory” (befriedigend). For “good” (gut), additions such as “stets” or “immer” (“always”) are typically expected, for example “stets zu unserer vollen Zufriedenheit” (“always to our full satisfaction”). For “very good” (sehr gut), “stets zu unserer vollsten Zufriedenheit” (“always to our fullest satisfaction”) is usually used. This gradation is not a statutory rule but reference language that is widespread in practice and that HR departments apply when reading. It matters above all for the question of who has to prove what: anyone who wants a grade better than “satisfactory” regularly needs facts in support, such as target agreements, appraisals, praise or successful projects. For a grade worse than “satisfactory”, by contrast, the employer bears the burden of presenting and proving the facts (Federal Labour Court (BAG), judgment of 18 November 2014, 9 AZR 584/13). The performance assessment should also be consistent with the assessment of conduct and the closing line; readers notice contradictions. I therefore read the reference as a whole and draft specific wording proposals rather than general criticism. In a termination agreement the grade can be agreed in advance. As at: November 2026.

May a reference contain hidden hints?

No, a reference must not contain hidden hints. It must be clear and comprehensible and must not contain features or wording that are meant to convey a concealed message beyond what the words say (Section 109(2) GewO). Ambiguous wording or conspicuous omissions of duties and qualities that would be usual for the position are problematic. I therefore read the reference for ambiguities and conspicuous gaps. At the same time the principle of truth applies: the employer must word the reference benevolently, but only within the bounds of truth. According to the case law of the Federal Labour Court, there is no entitlement to a closing line with thanks and good wishes (BAG, judgment of 25 January 2022, 9 AZR 146/21); it can, however, be agreed in a termination agreement or settlement. If you find a suspicious phrase, you should request a correction with a specific proposed wording. As at: November 2026.

Can I demand a better reference?

Yes. If statements are incorrect or the assessment does not match the facts, a claim for correction may come into consideration. For a grade better than “satisfactory” you generally have to present and prove the facts in support; for a worse grade the employer bears the burden of presenting and proving the facts (BAG, judgment of 18 November 2014, 9 AZR 584/13). Collect evidence such as target agreements, appraisals, praise and projects that show your performance. I usually begin out of court with a specific proposed wording rather than general criticism. If no agreement is reached, the correction can be sought before the labour court. Watch for contractual time limits (Ausschlussfristen) in the employment contract or a collective agreement, which can also cover the correction claim. If the separation is still ahead, grade and wording can be agreed in the termination agreement or settlement; a draft reference that the employee may submit in a court settlement can also be enforceable. As at: November 2026.

How should employers deal with a request for changes?

First check whether the request for changes is justified: the reference must remain truthful, and benevolence is only possible within the bounds of truth. Corrections are called for where statements are incorrect, duties are missing or the assessment does not match the documented facts. If the employee asks for a grade better than “satisfactory”, they regularly have to present facts in support. Wording with hidden messages is impermissible (Section 109(2) GewO) and should be changed in any case. Under the case law of the Federal Labour Court, a closing line with thanks and good wishes is not automatically owed, but it can be part of an agreement. Document appraisals and target achievement so that your assessment can be supported. I check which changes are justified and agree a solution that works for both sides. Where a reference follows the employee’s draft, the limit of truthfulness of the reference must be observed. As at: November 2026.

Arrange an introductory call

Reference to be reviewed? By phone, in English and German.

Request an introductory call

General information, as at 14 November 2026. It does not replace advice on your individual case.