Employment law
The closing line of a German employment reference: why thanks and good wishes are negotiable
According to the case law of the Federal Labour Court, there is no right to a closing formula expressing regret, thanks and good wishes.

Many references end with a sentence saying that the employer regrets the employee’s departure, thanks them for the cooperation and wishes them all the best. This is not owed: according to the case law of the Federal Labour Court, there is no right to such a closing formula. Anyone who wants it, or wants to avoid it, should therefore regulate it expressly, ideally in the termination agreement or the settlement.
Does an employment reference have to end with thanks and good wishes?
No. Section 109 of the German Trade Regulation Act (GewO) entitles employees to a written employment reference. On request, it must also cover performance and conduct. It must be clear and understandable (section 109(1) and (2) GewO). Expressions of regret, thanks and good wishes are not required. (§ 109)
The Federal Labour Court decided this in 2012 (BAG, Urt. v. 11.12.2012 – 9 AZR 227/11) and confirmed it in 2022 (BAG, Urt. v. 25.1.2022 – 9 AZR 146/21). Such sentences express the employer’s personal feelings. Obliging the employer to voice them would interfere with his freedom of expression. Nor does the duty of consideration under section 241(2) BGB support such a claim. (Section 241 (2))
And if the formula has been promised or is otherwise usual?
If the formula is promised in the contract, the employer owes it. Disputes then often arise over the wording: is it enough that regret, thanks and wishes are included, or can the employee demand a specific wording? That depends on the agreement. A clause that only promises “a closing formula” leaves room for interpretation, which both sides can avoid.
Whether a uniform reference practice on the employer’s part can lead to a different result is a matter for the individual case. Employers should therefore set their practice consciously and apply it consistently.
How is the formula agreed in a termination agreement or settlement?
In a termination agreement or court settlement, the closing formula can be fixed with little effort. These points help:
- Whether: an express promise that the reference contains a closing formula, or an express waiver of it.
- Components: name regret, thanks and wishes for the future individually.
- Wording: include the wording in the contract or in an annex, instead of merely promising a “benevolent” reference.
- Consistency: the formula should match the overall rating. An effusive close under a weak rating raises questions.
- Coordination: the reference clause and the settlement and release clause should fit together.
An example of such a clause: “The reference ends with a formula that expresses regret at the departure, thanks for the cooperation and good wishes for the future.” This makes clear that all three components are owed, without fixing the exact wording.
If an employment reference is agreed on the basis of the employee’s draft, the formula can be fixed in the draft straight away. See also the article on an employment reference based on a draft in a settlement. (employment reference by draft in settlement)
What matters for employers and employees?
For employers:
- Decide consciously whether a closing formula is part of your reference practice, and apply that decision consistently.
- Review standard wording and adapt it to the individual rating.
- In a settlement, promise only what is intended: whoever promises regret, thanks and wishes owes all three.
- Raise objections to the draft early and record them before the reference is issued.
For the employees:
- Raise the closing formula in the negotiation, not only after receiving the reference. Without an agreement, it cannot be enforced legally.
- Read the reference you receive and check whether the formula and the rating match.
- If in doubt, have the reference checked promptly.
Frequently asked questions
Can the employer simply leave out the closing formula?
In principle, yes, if no closing formula has been agreed. A reference without thanks and wishes may, however, read as sober to readers. Many employees therefore settle the formula in the termination agreement or settlement.
What components does an agreed closing formula contain?
Three elements are usual: regret at the departure, thanks for the cooperation and wishes for the future. Which of them are owed follows from the agreement. Anyone who wants to be sure names all the desired components expressly and, ideally, attaches the wording.
Must the employer use the formula if they otherwise always use it?
There is no general right to it. Whether a uniform practice in the business leads to a different result in an individual case can only be assessed on the basis of the specific circumstances. An express agreement is safer.
I check employment references and draft reference clauses in termination agreements and settlements, for employees, executives and employers. More on this under Having an employment reference checked in Munich. Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, in English if you wish. (Employment reference review in Munich)
For context: Employment law in Munich, with all focus areas at a glance. Also relevant: an employment reference based on the employee’s draft in a settlement and the settlement and release clause in a termination agreement. (settlement of employment references according to the employee's draft)
Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.
This article provides general information and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. As of November 2026.
More about consulting: Labour law for employers and SMEs. (Employment law for employers and SMEs)
