Employment law
Draft employment references in court settlements: what can be enforced?
Under the case law of the Federal Labour Court (BAG), a settlement clause providing that the employment reference follows the employee’s draft is enforceable, even if the employer may depart from it only for good reason.

In dismissal protection proceedings, the employment reference is often dealt with in a settlement, not infrequently based on the employee’s draft. The Federal Labour Court has decided that such a clause is enforceable, even if the employer may depart from the draft only for good reason (BAG, order of 7 May 2026 – 8 AZB 25/25). The limits are the truthfulness and clarity of the employment reference. In the case decided, the application for a coercive fine therefore failed.
What did the Federal Labour Court decide?
The basis was a settlement in dismissal protection proceedings: the employer promised a qualified, benevolent employment reference, the employee was allowed to submit a draft, and the employer was to depart from it only for good reason. The reference issued deviated from the draft, above all in the description of duties. The employee applied for a coercive fine under § 888 ZPO.
The regional labour court considered the settlement too vague because the draft was not yet available. The Federal Labour Court took a different view but let the coercive fine fail anyway: the employer had plausibly shown that parts of the draft might be untrue.
Is a reference to a draft submitted later sufficient?
Issuing an employment reference is an act that only the employer can perform. Under § 888 ZPO, it can be enforced by a coercive fine if the title is sufficiently specific. According to the order, it is sufficient for this purpose to refer to a draft that the employee submits only later, as long as it is clear which draft is to be decisive. In the case decided, the employee was still allowed to submit his draft in the enforcement proceedings. The right to depart for good reason also does not conflict with specificity: it concerns the limits of the claim, not its specificity.
In practice, this means: the draft is a strong means of pressure, but not a free pass. The employee may rely on it to the extent that it is true and clear. The employer does not have to sign anything inaccurate, but must be able to explain its objections plausibly. Anyone who already knows at the settlement stage which details are disputed can clarify them there.
Where does the right to submit a draft end?
A qualified employment reference serves as an application document and must be true, clear and comprehensible (§ 109 GewO). The right to specify a draft does not change that. Enforcement, too, must not lead to an untrue or unclear reference. According to the order, a breach of this is a good reason for departing from the draft.
The enforcement court does not itself examine whether the objections are correct. If, however, the employer plausibly presents circumstances that show a possible breach, the coercive fine is ruled out. The content of the reference must then be clarified in new judgment proceedings. The court left open whether a coercive fine can be considered where the objections are only partly justified.
How can the clause be worded for both sides?
For the employees:
- Keep the draft factual and verifiable. A description of duties that goes beyond what was actually performed jeopardises enforcement.
- Set deadlines for submitting the draft and issuing the employment reference.
- Agree disputed points such as titles, areas of responsibility or periods before the settlement is concluded.
- Agree specific key points such as tasks, assessment and closing line; general promises such as “benevolent” are likely to be harder to enforce. (Closing line)
For employers:
- Regulate the power to depart expressly, for example in the event of breaches of truthfulness or clarity, and provide a time limit and written form for objections.
- Review the draft before the settlement is concluded. A draft as an annex can reduce later disputes.
- Raise and document objections early, specifically and plausibly.
- Issue a truthful employment reference on time, even if the draft is not adopted in full.
Frequently asked questions
Does the employer have to adopt every draft of the employee?
No. The draft is binding only within the limits of the truthfulness and clarity of the employment reference. If the employer departs from it on these grounds, this may be a good reason within the meaning of the settlement clause. Whether the objections are justified in the individual case is, where necessary, clarified in new judgment proceedings.
How can an agreed employment reference be enforced?
If the employment reference is not issued, the employee can enforce the settlement. Issuing a reference is an act that only the employer can perform; under § 888 ZPO it can be enforced by a coercive fine and, in the alternative, coercive detention. This requires that the clause is sufficiently specific.
What is the advantage over a “benevolent qualified employment reference”?
A merely general promise leaves open what the reference should look like and can shift the dispute to enforcement. A draft as a benchmark makes the content tangible. Both sides should therefore check it when the settlement is concluded.
I draft employment reference clauses for settlements and termination agreements, for employees and employers alike. Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, in English on request. (Having an employment reference reviewed in Munich)
For context: Employment law in Munich, with all focus areas at a glance. Also important: closing line in employment references and dismissing managing directors. (Closing line in employment references)
Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.
For cost planning where additional claims are added, the article on the amount in dispute for continued employment and an interim reference explains the position. (Amount in dispute: continued employment and an interim employment reference)
This article is for general information and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. Legal position as at November 2026.
More on advice at management level: Employment law for executives and managing directors.
