Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Executives, bonuses and equity

Bad-leaver clauses: can vested equity be forfeited?

A bad-leaver label does not by itself settle whether vested rights can be cancelled. The clause, the award and the circumstances of departure need separate review.

Auf Deutsch lesen

Row of small brass coins on a dark table, the last few pushed out of line, beside a notebook.
This image is AI-generated.

What does “bad leaver” mean?

It is a contractual label. A plan may use it for particular resignations, misconduct or breaches of restrictions. Some plans also distinguish good and intermediate leavers. Read the definition together with the consequences: cancellation, a compulsory transfer and a repurchase at a specified price are different outcomes.

What did the Federal Labour Court decide?

The Federal Labour Court rejected standard terms under which vested virtual options were lost immediately on resignation. It also rejected a two-year forfeiture schedule following departure where the full vesting period was four years. The decision does not automatically apply to real shares or independent awards by another group company.

The vested options in that programme also rewarded work already performed. An uncertain future payout did not remove that character, and losing all earned rights could place an unreasonable obstacle in the way of changing jobs. This does not establish permanent protection against every forfeiture clause or automatically validate a different expiry period. The purpose and terms of the individual programme still matter.

Which questions matter for your award?

  • Which provision is relied on, and which grants does it cover?
  • Who gave notice, for what reason and with what termination date?
  • How many units had vested, and have any rights already been exercised?
  • Which company promised the award and which company is cancelling it?
  • If the clause is invalid, do the rights survive, or is another remedy available?

Does an invalid clause make me a good leaver?

Not automatically. Challenging forfeiture, establishing a different leaver classification and claiming immediate payment are separate issues. Even if rights survive, payment may still depend on an exit or another condition.

What should I do after a cancellation notice?

Keep the notice, attachments and evidence of when it arrived. Gather all award letters, plan rules and vesting statements. Before signing a confirmation, establish whether it merely acknowledges receipt or also accepts a loss of rights. A general objection does not necessarily preserve every contractual deadline, and waiting for a future exit may be inappropriate.

A first review can assess prospects, potential value and the effort involved. If valuation information is missing or the relevant company is abroad, a limited initial scope can help decide whether to request information, negotiate or prepare enforcement.

For HR and management: review your company’s VSOP programme and leaver provisions.

General information. Advice on an individual matter requires review of the relevant documents.

Next step

We agree the scope of work and fees before you instruct me.

Federal Labour Court, judgment of 19 March 2025, 10 AZR 67/24: forfeiture provisions for vested virtual options. Its scope must be distinguished from other bonus and equity arrangements.