Executives, bonuses and equity
Employee shares on termination: must you sell them back?
A repurchase demand should be checked against the complete share and employment documentation. Real shares, unexercised options and virtual units are different legal positions.

What is a call option?
A call option may allow a company or another entitled person to require the purchase of your shares when specified conditions arise. The agreement determines the trigger, the shares covered, how the option is exercised and the price. Once you are a shareholder, the articles of association and shareholder agreements can matter alongside your employment contract.
What should the review cover?
- Who is entitled to demand the shares?
- Has the contractual trigger occurred?
- Was the option exercised in the correct form and within the deadline?
- How many shares are affected?
- Which valuation date and price formula apply?
- Are there objections to the clause or to its application?
A price below your expected market value warrants scrutiny but does not alone prove that the clause is invalid. Equally, the phrase “bad leaver” is not a substitute for explaining the contractual basis of a price.
Do the rules for virtual units apply?
Not necessarily. Shareholder rights, a right to acquire shares and a contractual payment claim must be distinguished. The applicable employment and corporate law analysis depends on the agreement.
Does the dispute belong in a labour court?
Not always. A dispute about rights under an independent shareholder agreement may belong in the civil courts. The issue can concern the claimant’s position as a shareholder, rather than an employment obligation. Acquiring the shares in connection with employment does not by itself establish labour court jurisdiction; an additional direct employment connection requires separate examination.
What should I check before signing a transfer?
Determine whether the document only implements technical transfer steps or also accepts the price, the validity of the repurchase obligation or a release of further claims. Separate the timing of necessary declarations from the preservation of objections. A review should address both the asserted obligation and any further corporate law advice required.
For HR and management: review your company’s VSOP programme and leaver provisions.
General information. Advice on an individual matter requires review of the relevant documents.
For advice on your documents: review your employee equity.
Primary source and scope
Federal Labour Court, order of 29 August 2025, 9 AZB 4/25: jurisdiction for a claim concerning an independent shareholder agreement; paragraphs 23–30 also address related-claim jurisdiction under section 2(3) ArbGG.
