Executives, bonuses and equity
Employee equity claims: labour court or civil court?
The right court depends on the claim, the parties and the contractual basis. An employment connection alone does not make every equity dispute a labour court case.

Why does the contractual basis matter?
A participation programme may involve employment rights, an independent payment promise or a shareholder agreement. After acquiring real shares, a dispute may concern shareholder status. In another case, the claimant may seek payment under an employer’s own promise. Start with the precise relief sought.
Which situations need to be distinguished?
An isolated dispute under an independent shareholder agreement can belong in the civil courts. A different result may follow where an equity claim has a legal or direct economic connection with an employment claim already pending or brought at the same time. Related-claim jurisdiction also requires that no other court has exclusive jurisdiction over the additional claim.
This is not a general exception for every group-company award. A leaver clause alone does not establish all the requirements for related-claim jurisdiction.
An employment claim filed only later does not generally create related-claim jurisdiction retrospectively. The timing and sequence of the claims can therefore matter.
What needs to be established before proceedings?
- The payment, declaration or other remedy sought.
- The correct defendant and the legal basis of the claim.
- Any connected employment dispute.
- Jurisdiction and arbitration clauses.
- Any foreign element requiring an additional jurisdiction analysis.
Is choice of law the same as jurisdiction?
No. A German-law clause does not automatically identify the competent court. Where a foreign company is involved, international jurisdiction and the appropriate branch of the courts need separate consideration.
What about an arbitration clause?
The possible effect of an arbitration clause on the admissibility of proceedings is separate from allocation between labour and civil courts. Identifying the appropriate branch of the courts does not determine whether an arbitration clause is valid or prevents the court proceedings.
How can the initial work be kept proportionate?
First identify the claim, defendant, documents and deadlines. That provides a basis for choosing between a request for information, negotiations and litigation preparation. The approach should be proportionate to the potential economic outcome.
For HR and management: review your company’s VSOP programme and leaver provisions.
General information. Advice on an individual matter requires review of the relevant documents.
For advice on your documents: review your employee equity.
Primary source and scope
Federal Labour Court, order of 29 August 2025, 9 AZB 4/25: jurisdiction for a claim concerning an independent shareholder agreement; paragraphs 23–30 also address related-claim jurisdiction under section 2(3) ArbGG.
