Dismissal and legal protection
Capacity to conduct proceedings before a labour court: what expert opinions can establish
Mental illness does not automatically mean incapacity to conduct proceedings. What is decisive is the ability to exercise free will in the relevant area. Where there are concrete doubts, the court must clarify this requirement of its own motion and give the persons concerned a legal hearing.

What capacity to conduct proceedings means
Capacity to conduct proceedings concerns the ability to conduct court proceedings through one’s own effective procedural acts or to instruct a representative effectively. It is to be distinguished from the question of whether the claim has any prospect of success on the merits. Even contentious or unusual submissions do not answer the question of capacity by themselves.
In the case of adults, the civil procedure test is in principle linked to the capacity to enter into contracts. What matters are the statutory requirements and the concrete ability to exercise free will. A diagnosis, a degree of disability or a long conflict with the employer does not replace this examination.
When the court needs to clarify more
If there are concrete indications that capacity to conduct proceedings is lacking, the court must investigate the question of its own motion under section 56 ZPO. This may also become necessary in proceedings that are already well advanced. The clarification does not take place solely on the basis of the other party’s submissions; the court must obtain a sound basis of its own for its decision.
In decision 4 Ta 200/23, the LAG Munich dealt with capacity to conduct proceedings in the context of a complaint in labour court proceedings. It evaluated several sources of information and based its finding in particular on a current psychiatric expert opinion. The parties had been given an opportunity to address the opinion and to suggest additional questions.
The significance of an expert opinion from another proceeding
Section 411a ZPO allows, under its conditions, the use of an expert opinion obtained by a court or the public prosecutor’s office in another proceeding. Origin, the question examined and probative value must be considered. An expert opinion on an earlier condition does not answer the current capacity to conduct proceedings without further evaluation.
In the Munich proceedings, older expert opinions and their use were also in dispute. The court had in addition arranged for a current expert opinion. The decision should therefore not be reduced to the statement that an old expert opinion makes any further clarification unnecessary.
The scope must be determined precisely
The legal assessment may concern a limited range of matters. In the case decided, the LAG accepted partial incapacity to conduct proceedings for labour court proceedings. No general statement about all areas of life or about other people with a comparable diagnosis can be derived from this.
Criminal incapacity, incapacity for work and incapacity to conduct proceedings also denote different tests. Which representation and which procedural steps are required must be clarified for the specific situation. Medical assessments should be left to qualified professionals.
What a sound preparation looks like
- Discuss court notices and current deadlines without delay with suitable legal representation.
- Establish the question actually put to the expert and the period examined.
- Formulate additional questions or objections concretely and comprehensibly.
- Transmit health records only by an agreed confidential route.
- Clarify necessary questions of representation in good time.
For a first contact, the status of the proceedings, the next date and a brief description of the court’s notice are enough. Detailed diagnoses and expert opinions should not be sent unprotected through a general contact form. Dealing with deadlines requires a separate legal review.
Legal bases and sources
LAG Munich, decision of 19 February 2026 – 4 Ta 200/23. The account is limited to the procedural questions; it is not based on separate proof that the decision has become final.
- § 51 ZPO – capacity to conduct proceedings and representation
- § 52 ZPO – Scope of capacity to conduct proceedings
- Section 56 ZPO – Examination ex officio
- Section 411a ZPO – other expert opinions
- § 104 BGB – Incapacity to enter into contracts
Legal position and source check: 7 November 2026. General legal information; for the assessment of an individual case, the specific documents and deadlines are decisive.
For advice on your situation: Employment law advice in English.
