Employment law news
Dismissal for leaving a church ruled invalid: what the 2026 Federal Labour Court decision means
On 5 November 2026, the Federal Labour Court declared invalid the dismissal of a social educator in Catholic pregnancy counselling because she had left the church (2 AZR 196/22).

In short: leaving the church is not a general ground for dismissal. Church employers may only require church membership if it is essential for the specific activity. That is lacking where the same work is also done by employees of other faiths or none. The decision affects hundreds of thousands of employees at Caritas, Diakonie and other church institutions.
What was the case about?
The claimant worked as a social educator in the pregnancy counselling service of a Catholic association. In 2013 she left the Catholic Church; according to reports, the special church levy (Kirchgeld) raised in the Diocese of Limburg played a part. She declared her departure to the state authority and did not make it public. After talks about re-joining had failed, the employer dismissed her summarily and, in the alternative, with notice. At the same time, however, it also employed counsellors in the same counselling centre who were not Catholic.
The lower courts ruled in the claimant’s favour. In 2024, the Federal Labour Court referred the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union, as it concerned the interpretation of the European equal treatment directive.
What did the European Court of Justice say?
In its judgment of 17 March 2026 (C-258/24, Katholische Schwangerschaftsberatung), the Court of Justice of the European Union held that a Catholic association may not, in principle, dismiss an employee solely because she has left the Church, at least not where it also employs people who are not Catholic for the same work. Under Article 4(2) of Directive 2000/78/EC, church employers may rely on religion only if it is an essential, lawful and justified occupational requirement for the activity.
The CJEU also stressed that leaving the church does not in itself have to mean a rejection of the church’s fundamental values. It is for the employer to show that, without the requirement, there is a probable and substantial risk to its ethos or its right of self-determination. It left the final assessment to the Federal Labour Court.
How did Federal Labour Court decide?
The Federal Labour Court dismissed the employer’s appeal on points of law on 5 November 2026 (2 AZR 196/22). According to the court’s press release and the reports available, both dismissals are invalid:
- Direct discrimination on the basis of religion: The dismissal is linked to her leaving the church and thus disadvantages the claimant on the basis of her religion. A justification under § 9 AGG is ruled out because church membership was not an essential requirement for the counselling work: the employer also used non-Catholic staff for the same task.
- No breach of loyalty: Leaving the church, without making it public, was not disloyal conduct that could justify unequal treatment.
- Two-week period missed: The summary dismissal was also invalid because it was not declared within two weeks of the employer becoming aware of the facts (§ 626 (2) BGB). (Section 626 (2) BGB)
According to reports, the claimant can demand outstanding pay and compensation. Compensation for discrimination is provided for in § 15 (2) AGG. (Section 15 (2) AGG)
What does the judgment mean for employees of church employers?
For employees of Caritas, Diakonie, church hospitals, day care centres or counselling centres, the following applies after the decision:
- The specific activity counts. The less a task has to do with proclaiming the faith or the religious character of the institution, and the more colleagues of other faiths do the same work, the harder it is to justify a dismissal for leaving the church.
- Leaving the church is not automatically disloyalty. Anyone who leaves the church without publicly turning against it does not necessarily breach a duty of loyalty.
- Different rules may apply to tasks close to the proclamation of the faith. For pastoral care, religious education or leadership roles with a church character, church membership may be an essential requirement. This must be examined in each individual case.
- Keep to the time limits. A claim against a dismissal must be brought within three weeks (§ 4 KSchG). Claims for compensation under the AGG must be asserted in writing within two months (§ 15 (4) AGG). (Section 4 KSchG · Section 15 (4) AGG)
How a claim for protection against dismissal proceeds is explained on the page “Claim for protection against dismissal in Munich”. Basics on time limits and grounds: “Dismissal with notice: time limits, grounds and first steps”. (Claim for protection against dismissal in Munich · Dismissal with notice: time limits, grounds and first steps)
What should church employers check now?
- Evaluate job profiles: For which roles is church membership genuinely essential? The reasoning should be comprehensible and consistent.
- Consistent practice: An employer that uses employees of different faiths for the same task can hardly present membership as mandatory.
- Conduct dismissal procedures properly: For summary dismissals, the two-week period runs from becoming aware of the facts. Talks about re-joining do not extend it automatically; see the article on this topic. (Summary dismissal: internal investigations and the two-week time limit)
- Adapt application procedures: The same standards apply to the question of whether church membership may be required in job advertisements.
Advice for institutions and human resources departments: employment law for employers.
Frequently asked questions about dismissal for leaving a church
Can a church employer dismiss me for leaving the church?
Only as an exception. Church membership must be an essential and justified requirement for the specific activity. If the employer also uses employees without this church membership for the same task, a dismissal solely because of leaving the church is, in principle, invalid under the Federal Labour Court’s judgment of 5 November 2026.
Does the judgment also apply to Protestant institutions?
The standards of the Equal Treatment Directive and § 9 AGG apply to all religious communities and their institutions. Whether a requirement is justified, however, always depends on the specific activity.
Do I have to tell my employer if I leave the church?
There is no general statutory duty. Employment contracts or church basic regulations may contain duties to notify; their validity must be examined in each individual case.
What can I demand after an invalid dismissal?
Possible claims are continued employment, pay for the interim period and, in the case of discrimination on the basis of religion, compensation under the AGG. Short time limits apply.
Conclusion: leaving the church alone does not justify a dismissal
The Federal Labour Court consistently implements the CJEU’s requirements. Church employers will in future have to justify, for each role, why church membership is really essential. For employees, this means that a dismissal for leaving the church should always be reviewed, within the time limit for bringing a claim.
If you have received a dismissal from a church employer, Kanzlei Osuji advises employees and institutions nationwide. The introductory call helps clarify your situation and does not include a document review. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. (Request an introductory call)
Author: Noah Osuji, attorney. As of 8 November 2026. The facts are based on the press releases and reports mentioned. This article provides general information and does not replace individual legal advice. The cover image is an AI-generated icon graphic.
If you have received a dismissal from a church employer, you have three weeks in principle to bring a claim. Calculate the deadline now. (Calculate the deadline now)
For advice on your situation: Employment law advice in English.
Sources and date
- Federal Labour Court: Press release “Dismissal for leaving the church” (5 November 2026, 2 AZR 196/22) (Press release “Dismissal for leaving the church”)
- Court of Justice of the European Union: Press release on judgment C-258/24 (17 March 2026) (Press release on the judgment C-258/24)
