Dismissal and legal protection
Conditional dismissal: when can a notice of termination be invalid?
A notice of termination must be sufficiently clear to show the intention to terminate. If its effect depends on a future uncertain court decision, it may be ineffective. The precise wording and the legal context are decisive.

When there are several options in writing
In a restructuring, a transfer, a dismissal with an offer of amended terms and a dismissal to end the employment may coincide in time. A letter must nevertheless make clear which specific declaration the employer is making. Employees should be able to assess whether and on what conditions their employment relationship is to end.
Unclear references to other procedures can make this orientation difficult. The review therefore requires the complete letter, including attachments, and the preceding correspondence. A single sentence from an e-mail often does not yet answer the question of effectiveness.
What the LAG Hessen had to assess
Case 14 SLa 107/25 concerned a dismissal for operational reasons in connection with earlier dismissals with an offer of amended terms and an intended transfer. According to the letter, the termination was to depend, among other things, on how the labour court would decide on the replacement of a refused works council consent.
The LAG already considered the declaration not sufficiently specific. It remained unclear which conditions were to trigger or prevent the termination and which transfer was being referred to. It also objected to the link with the future court event as an inadmissible condition.
Why future dependence was problematic
A dismissal shapes the employment relationship unilaterally. A state of suspense that is resolved only by a future uncertain event is therefore in principle problematic. In the case decided, the court decision on the replacement of consent was still pending when the notice of termination was received.
The court assessed this situation neither as a mere legal condition nor as a condition whose occurrence depends solely on a decision by the employee. This distinction matters: not every mention of another procedure automatically leads to ineffectiveness. The link actually declared remains decisive.
“Precautionary” or “auxiliary” alone does not decide anything
Employers may declare a dismissal as a precaution or in the alternative, for example where the effectiveness of an earlier termination is disputed. Such terms are not, in themselves, proof of an inadmissible condition. What needs to be clarified is whether a clear intention to terminate is declared and what a reservation relates to.
A further dismissal must therefore be reviewed separately. Even after successful action against a first letter, a later declaration may trigger a new time limit for bringing a claim. Employees should not rely on proceedings already under way automatically covering every further dismissal.
Which documents and questions count now
- All dismissals and offers of amended terms in chronological order.
- Declarations of acceptance and, where applicable, reservations declared.
- Details of the planned role and the place of work.
- Works council documents and decisions on the replacement of consent, where available.
- Dates of receipt of the respective letters.
Works council consent to a transfer under the Works Constitution Act and the effectiveness of a dismissal involve different reviews. Employers should coordinate these procedures and their declarations precisely. Even where a letter is obviously unclear, employees should have the time limit for bringing a claim, in principle three weeks, secured.
Legal bases and sources
Hessisches LAG, judgment of 6 March 2026 – 14 SLa 107/25. The account concerns the specific notice of termination and does not confirm that the judgment has been separately shown to be final.
- § 133 BGB – Interpretation of a declaration of intent
- Section 1 KSchG – protection against dismissal
- Section 99 BetrVG – individual personnel measures
- Section 4 KSchG – time limit for bringing a claim
Legal status and source verification: 7 November 2026. General legal information; the specific documents and deadlines are decisive for the assessment of an individual case.
For advice on your situation: Employment law advice in English.
