Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Managing director separation

Dismissal of a managing director by the supervisory board: when does section 174 BGB apply?

When terminating a managing director’s service agreement, the representative competent under the articles of association must be checked.

Read the German original

Documents, a pen and a closed folder on a conference table.
This image is AI-generated.

When a company separates from a managing director, the resolution to dismiss is not the only thing that matters. Who signs the letter and what authority to represent is proved can also decide whether the dismissal is valid. On 7 May 2026, the Federal Labour Court gave an important decision on this.

Who may terminate a managing director’s service agreement?

In principle, the shareholders’ meeting of a GmbH is responsible for ending the managing director’s service agreement. However, the articles of association may provide for a different competence of a supervisory board established under company law. The resolution of the corporate body, the ending of the contract and external representation must therefore be examined separately. The removal of the managing director from office under § 38 GmbHG also does not automatically end the managing director’s service agreement.

For companies and managing directors, what matters is who passes the resolution to dismiss, who declares the dismissal and whether that person’s authority to represent has been proved to the recipient.

What did the Federal Labour Court decide on 7 May 2026?

In judgment 2 AZR 130/25, the Federal Labour Court considered a dismissal notice signed by members of a GmbH supervisory board that was competent under the articles of association. The recipient promptly rejected the notice because proof of authority to act was missing. The court confirmed that the dismissal was invalid, applying section 174 of the German Civil Code (BGB) by analogy. (§ 174 BGB)

The decisive difference: representation by the supervisory board as a whole and a separately granted power of individual representation, where applicable, are not the same. Such authorisation may require proof that the recipient of the declaration can recognise. The details of the articles of association and of the prior notification are decisive.

What risks arise if a notice of termination is rejected?

An effective rejection without undue delay may mean that the dismissal does not end the contractual relationship. The company faces continuing claims to remuneration and, where applicable, the need for a new, proper dismissal. The court decided on the basis of the particular procedural starting position of an employment relationship that was undisputed; it cannot be inferred that every managing director is an employee.

Time limits for bringing a claim, written form and how to deal with a further dismissal must also be examined separately. The case shows that a decision to separate that is understandable on the merits is not enough if its implementation is formally defective.

What should the managing director and the company check?

  • Do the articles of association contain an effective rule on the competence of the supervisory board?
  • Is external representation provided for by the body as a whole or by authorised members?
  • Is proof of authority to represent or prior notification required?
  • When was the dismissal letter received, and was any rejection declared without delay?
  • Are there separate issues of remuneration, bonus or liability?

For how the separation steps interact, see the advice page on separating from managing directors in Munich and the article on termination agreements for managing directors. (Advice page on managing director separation in Munich)

Frequently asked questions

Can a supervisory board chair terminate the contract alone?

Not on the strength of the job title alone. The specific articles of association and, where applicable, a valid authorisation to represent the company are decisive.

Does a valid supervisory board resolution automatically make the dismissal effective?

No. Passing the resolution, the authority to declare the dismissal and the required questions of form or proof must be examined separately.

If you would like to have a specific case examined, please contact Kanzlei Osuji in Munich or +49 174 343 0142. (Contact Kanzlei Osuji in Munich)

As of: 6 November 2026. Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer. General information, no individual case advice. AI-generated icon image; no representation of actual participants in the process.

Next step

We agree the scope of work and fees before you instruct me.