Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Executives, bonuses and equity

Summary dismissal of an executive: the limits of their authority

An executive may not deliberately bypass binding personnel decisions solely because of their own operational concerns. Whether this gives rise to an important reason for dismissal, however, depends on authority, instructions, fault and the concrete consequences.

Read the German original

An empty leather chair behind a desk with a closed folder, fountain pen and rubber stamp.
This image is AI-generated.

The case: Personnel decision despite reconciliation of interests

According to the findings of the LAG Rhineland-Palatinate, the head of a business division arranged for an employee to continue working beyond the end of his fixed term. This contradicted the decision of the managing directors and the staff reduction concept of a reconciliation of interests. The court held the summary dismissal of the head of division to be effective in the specific case.

The problem was not merely an unfortunate sequence of events. The chamber regarded the deliberate disregard of the requirements as a serious breach of trust. Continued employment could also trigger financial risks and consequences for other proceedings for protection against dismissal.

Why good intentions alone are not enough

An executive may have operational reasons for deploying staff for longer. This does not by itself give them the authority to override a binding decision to the contrary. In a dispute, it must be clarified what room for manoeuvre actually existed, what coordination took place and which limits were known. The job title in the employment contract or a managerial function does not replace this examination.

What consequences unilateral continued employment can have

Under a restructuring concept, individual personnel decisions may be connected with social selection, name lists, employment opportunities and collective redundancy issues. An additional employee who is kept on may affect the assumptions on which the dismissal of other people is based. Whether and which legal consequences arise depends on the respective provisions and facts.

A reconciliation of interests is not simply an ordinary works agreement with the same effect. Disregarding it may in particular raise questions of compensation for disadvantages under section 113 BetrVG. The different legal effects should not be mixed up under the term “personnel plan”.

Is a disciplinary warning required before dismissal?

Where the conduct is controllable, a disciplinary warning is as a rule considered as a milder measure. Exceptions may exist if a change in behaviour is not to be expected or if a particularly serious breach of duty obviously cannot be tolerated. The LAG regarded a prior disciplinary warning as unnecessary given the deliberate conduct it had found.

This is no licence to impose summary dismissal for every faulty management decision. Among other things, the clarity of the instruction, knowledge, fault, gravity, possible approvals and the balancing of interests must still be examined. The two-week time limit under section 626 (2) BGB is also a separate question.

Practical preparation if an allegation is made

  • Assemble the employment contract, the allocation of competences and personnel powers of attorney.
  • Secure specific instructions, exceptions and evidence of coordination.
  • Document the sequence of events completely and objectively.
  • Keep the dismissal letter and the date of receipt ready for checking the time limits.

A person employed as an executive is not automatically a member of a corporate body or a senior executive (leitender Angestellter) in every statutory sense. Their actual position is decisive for the appropriate legal protection.

Legal bases and sources

LAG Rhineland-Palatinate, judgment of 19 August 2026 – 6 SLa 247/25. An appeal on points of law was not admitted; no additional proof of finality is derived from this here.

Legal status and source check: 7 November 2026. General information; the evaluation of a specific case requires the complete documentation.

Clarify your next steps

Kanzlei Osuji advises in Munich and nationwide. The introductory call helps clarify your situation and does not include a document review. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. Please mention any deadlines that are running when you get in touch.

Request an introductory call