Dismissal and legal protection
Threats during a personnel meeting: allegations and dismissal
Complaints about a personnel meeting do not automatically justify dismissal. Substantially untrue statements of fact may be different. What matters are the established course of the conversation, the specific statement and the balancing of interests.

What was disputed in the decided case
After a personnel meeting, an employee claimed that he had been threatened with psychological wearing down. The LAG Rheinland-Pfalz held the summary dismissal to be valid in case 6 SLa 144/25. The chamber relied on extensive taking of evidence and on its finding that the statement in question was untrue. It also assessed the considerable effects on continued cooperation.
The case therefore does not establish a general rule that employees may report a threat only once they have evidence that will stand up in court. A conversation that cannot be clarified and a substantially untrue statement that has been established are different starting points.
Separating statement of fact, impression and legal assessment
The statement that a particular person said a particular sentence can, in principle, be tested for its truth. A description of one’s own feelings or a legal assessment must be distinguished from this. In practice, the two can be mixed. Precise wording, addressees, timing and available evidence are therefore important.
True complaints, permissible criticism and justified exercise of rights do not lose their protection merely because the employer finds them unpleasant. Rules protecting complaints and reports must also be considered separately, depending on the facts.
Why the individual case still matters
Under section 626 BGB, summary dismissal requires an important reason and a balancing of the specific interests. Even a serious allegation does not replace this examination. Among other things, the following must be considered: the gravity and circumstances of the breach of duty, fault, effects, the course of the employment relationship so far and possible milder measures. Whether a disciplinary warning is required cannot therefore be inferred from the keyword “false claim”.
What employees can do after a stressful interview
- Promptly prepare a factual note from memory with the date, the people present and the wording as exact as possible.
- Separate your own perception from conclusions and hearsay.
- Name existing documents that were obtained lawfully, and witnesses.
- Before distributing serious allegations widely, take advice on the form and the competent bodies.
Secret audio recordings are not a harmless way of securing evidence. They can themselves cause problems under criminal and employment law. Discuss lawful ways of documenting events.
What employers should clarify before responding
The allegation must be investigated. A mere denial by superiors is not enough as a substitute for examining the facts. Depending on the measure, rights to be heard and rights of participation must be observed. The two-week period under section 626(2) BGB and its specific start must also be checked. An employment law assessment should not prematurely equate the complaint with a culpable false claim.
A dismissal triggers its own time limit
Anyone who receives a written dismissal must, in principle, bring a claim for protection against dismissal within three weeks of receipt. This also applies if the content of a conversation or a complaint is still being negotiated. Keep the notice of dismissal, the envelope, your note from memory and the subsequent correspondence ready for review.
Legal bases and sources
- § 626 BGB – summary dismissal
- Section 241 BGB – Duties of consideration
- Section 4 KSchG – time limit for bringing a claim
LAG Rheinland-Pfalz, judgment of 24 June 2026 – 6 SLa 144/25. This account is not based on any confirmation that the judgment has become final.
Legal position and source check: 7 November 2026. General information; assessing a specific case requires the complete documents.
If a statement is only challenged in court proceedings, the separate classification to litigation fraud helps. (Allegations of fraud in court proceedings: can an employer dismiss the employee?)
For advice on your situation: Employment law advice in English.
