Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Dismissal and legal protection

Allegations of fraud in court proceedings: can an employer dismiss the employee?

An accusation does not become litigation fraud simply because an employee denies it in court and the court later decides differently. On the other hand, deliberately invented facts can have significant consequences. The specific submissions and the history of the case are decisive.

Read the German original

A stack of case files tied with red ribbon beside a balance scale in front of bookshelves.
This image is AI-generated.

A new letter of dismissal during the proceedings

An employee challenges a disciplinary warning. After taking evidence, the court considers the original allegation to be proven. The employer then dismisses the employee because of allegedly false statements in the first proceedings. In this situation, the earlier allegation, the conduct in the proceedings and the new dismissal must be examined carefully and separately.

This was precisely the sequence in the case before the LAG Lower Saxony. The employment of a long-serving employee could not be terminated with notice under the collective agreement. The employer declared a summary dismissal with a social phase-out period. The LAG held it invalid and gave several independently sufficient grounds.

Why denying an allegation requires a separate examination

An employer must set out and, where necessary, prove the facts on which it bases a measure under employment law. The fact that the person concerned objects and does not succeed with their account in court does not in itself answer the question whether there has been a new breach of duty.

The LAG distinguished between denying an allegation and actively asserting claims that are knowingly untrue. In the proceedings decided, it did not consider the limit of permissible defence to have been exceeded. Nor did naming a witness for the defence prove, in itself, any dishonest influence. For the conduct of the proceedings in a specific case, the duty of truthfulness under section 138 ZPO and the respective duties to make declarations remain decisive.

What the disciplinary warning already issued means

The employer had itself first responded to the original conduct with a disciplinary warning. In the LAG’s view, under the circumstances of the case it could not then make the same core allegation the basis of a dismissal again merely because it was denied in the earlier proceedings.

This does not mean that every later act is protected. A new breach of duty in its own right, for example proven manipulation of evidence, would have to be assessed separately. It is therefore important which additional facts are actually alleged and substantiated.

A balance of interests remains necessary

The LAG also relied on the long length of service and the employee’s specific need for social protection. Even on the different assessment of the submissions in the proceedings that it considered in the alternative, the balancing of interests would have had to come out in the employee’s favour.

The judgment therefore does not support a general statement that every error in a party’s submissions to the court is without consequence. Nor can a sufficient ground for dismissal be derived automatically from the buzzword litigation fraud. Fault, the gravity of the alleged breach of duty and possible less severe measures are part of the examination.

How to prepare for the legal review

  • Compile the disciplinary warning, the first claim, pleadings and court decisions.
  • Mark the specific statement complained of, with its wording and date.
  • Keep apart your own perception, conclusions and mere uncertainty of memory.
  • Secure existing documents that were lawfully obtained; do not alter any documents.
  • Record each additional dismissal with its own date of receipt.

Employees should inform their legal representative immediately of any further dismissal. Employers should check whether they are really assessing new facts or merely giving a different name to an allegation already dealt with. For each new written notice of dismissal, a separate three-week period must in principle be observed.

Legal bases and sources

LAG Lower Saxony, judgment of 29 April 2026 – 8 SLa 894/25. Leave to appeal on points of law was not granted; this account is not based on separate proof of legal finality.

Legal position and source check: 7 November 2026. General legal information; the specific documents and deadlines are decisive for the assessment of an individual case.

Clarify your next steps

Kanzlei Osuji advises in Munich and nationwide. The introductory call helps clarify your situation and does not include a document review. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. Please mention any deadlines that are running when you get in touch.

Request an introductory call