Employers, pay and works councils
Internal investigations: common mistakes and how employers can avoid them
Most mistakes in internal investigations are organisational: starting too late, unclear responsibilities, no defined goal and a lack of steering.

In short: An internal investigation succeeds if it starts early, has a clear goal, is prepared in compliance with data protection law, is conducted with an open mind and is steered continuously. If one of these is missing, there is a risk of problems using the evidence, ineffective dismissals, unnecessary costs and liability risks for the management. This guide shows the typical mistakes along the four phases of planning, execution, report and follow-up.
Phase 1: What mistakes happen at the beginning of an internal investigation?
Starting too late, for fear of the two-week time limit
Many companies hesitate to clarify matters because they believe that the very start of the investigation sets the two-week period for summary dismissal running (section 626(2) BGB). The opposite is true. According to the settled case law of the Federal Labour Court, the period begins only when the party entitled to dismiss knows the relevant facts. As long as that party takes the steps needed to clarify the matter promptly, including examining exonerating circumstances, the start of the period is suspended. Waiting without taking any investigative steps, by contrast, is harmful. (Section 626 (2) BGB)
At the end of the fact-finding, the essential facts should be summarised in an (interim) report and submitted to the body that decides on the dismissal. From then on, the period runs. How courts assess this in individual cases is shown in the article “Summary dismissal: internal investigations and the two-week time limit”. What a missed deadline can cost is illustrated by the case “VW ordered to pay a former manager around €300,000 in arrears”. (Summary dismissal: internal investigations and the two-week time limit · VW has to pay ex-manager around 300,000 euros)
A late start also has practical consequences. Deletion routines destroy emails and logs, memories fade, those involved are warned and can remove traces, and money flows become harder to trace. In the end, the full proof that a dismissal or a claim for damages requires is often missing.
Liability risk for management and supervisory board
Since the ARAG/Garmenbeck decision of the Federal Court of Justice (judgment of 21 April 1997, II ZR 175/95), the supervisory board of a German stock corporation must examine whether the company has damages claims against members of the management board. It must in principle pursue those claims unless compelling reasons of the company’s interests weigh against doing so. The governing bodies must therefore be able to decide on an informed basis, and that requires a timely and adequate investigation. Anyone who fails to carry one out risks personal liability. On protecting members of governing bodies, see D&O insurance and employee liability.
The wrong team: too small, too large or without decision-making authority
If only one department investigates, for example HR or internal audit, expertise from other areas is often missing, and nobody has the authority to release resources across departments. If the circle is too large, disputes over competence, coordination effort and the risk of information leaking out arise.
As a rule of thumb, the size and composition of the team depend on the allegation and the need for confidentiality. An isolated allegation of harassment can be clarified in a small circle with the HR department. A suspected cartel, by contrast, needs sales, finance, legal and HR. Employment law expertise is always sensible where employees may be involved. And involve early someone who may quickly access mailboxes and servers on the IT side: obtaining the data is regularly the bottleneck. The composition should be reviewed and adjusted as the investigation progresses.
External advisers: helpful, but not an end in themselves
External lawyers, forensic service providers or industry experts bring neutrality and specialist knowledge, for example where internal investigators have to question colleagues with whom they continue to work. However, a visible presence in the company too early can attract attention and encourage concealment. Investigative steps carried out remotely, which stay inconspicuous until the interview phase, have proved their worth. The central interviews of suspects, by contrast, should take place in person.
Works council: involve selectively and confidentially
Whether and to what extent the works council must be involved in internal investigations is disputed and depends on the planned measures, for example technical analyses. In practice, selective, confidential information of the works council chair or chairs has proved its worth. It corresponds to the duty of cooperation based on trust (section 2 BetrVG) and makes the later consultation of the works council before a dismissal easier (section 102 BetrVG), without endangering confidentiality. (Section 2 of the BetrVG · Section 102 BetrVG)
Data protection before data backup
A particularly consequential mistake: mailboxes are copied and searched “on the off chance” before the initial suspicion and the investigation objective are documented. For the detection of criminal offences in the employment relationship, section 26(1) sentence 2 BDSG requires documented factual indications and a proportionality test. If this is made up afterwards instead of being done beforehand, prohibitions on using the evidence threaten, and as a result ineffective disciplinary warnings or dismissals.
- Keep the circle of persons affected narrow: evaluate data of superiors, colleagues or occasional contacts only if there is a separate, documented reason for doing so.
- Take private use into account: if private email use is permitted or tolerated, higher requirements apply; private messages are in principle off limits.
- Document extensions separately: each extension needs a specific reason.
- Inform the insurer early: if there is fidelity insurance, the insurer should be informed of the investigation in good time to avoid breaches of policy obligations.
Assistance with the data protection pre-examination: data protection law for companies.
No defined goal
Perhaps the most common basic mistake: nobody defines what the investigation is meant to clarify and which hypotheses are to be tested. Without this, direction is missing, and the investigation becomes longer, more expensive and less focused. At the start, therefore, formulate a preliminary goal, testable hypotheses and the decision to be taken at the end, for example dismissal, damages, a report to the authorities or a change of process.
Phase 2: What errors happen during the investigation?
Lack of focus and “by-catch”
Without a goal, every secondary finding is pursued with the same priority as the original suspicion. This drives up data volumes and costs. It becomes risky under employment law if one person is investigated in every direction: this can look like an unprompted special audit and lead the court to find the measures disproportionate.
The “by-catch” is particularly delicate: if the actual allegation cannot be proven, investigators switch to conduct that has been tolerated for years, for example in expense claims. In the balancing of interests, labour courts take into account whether the employer accepted such a practice or encouraged it through its own incentive systems. Here a disciplinary warning may be the appropriate measure, not dismissal.
Tunnel vision: exonerating points are overlooked
Investigators tend to take sides early and to examine conflicting statements less carefully. This is particularly clear in situations where one statement stands against another, for example allegations of sexual harassment. Here it is not enough to regard one person as more credible. Further sources of evidence, interviews of third parties and an examination that is comprehensible in both directions are needed.
The Federal Labour Court expressly requires this openness. Before a dismissal on suspicion, the employer must hear the employee on the specific allegations and give the employee the opportunity to present exonerating circumstances. If these produce leads, the employer must follow them up. How allegations in a personnel meeting are to be assessed legally is shown in the article “Threats during a personnel meeting: allegations and dismissal”. (Threats during a personnel meeting: allegations and dismissal)
Steering: who decides when enough has been investigated?
If the suspicion shifts, for example from a general compliance issue to a specific allegation against an employee, the steering committee must be adjusted as well. Often it stays unchanged. It is equally rare to check whether further steps still have an appropriate marginal benefit, for example where allegations are time-barred or the effort exceeds the possible damage many times over. External advisers should address cost and benefit openly; the company retains control.
If reliable evidence for the pending decision is already available, not every further side issue needs to be investigated to the end. Regular steering meetings, depending on the scope about every two weeks, with three fixed questions have proved their worth:
- Is the committee still properly composed?
- Is the effort, including that of external advisers, still proportionate to the knowledge gained?
- Is the current state already sufficient for the pending decision?
Phase 3: What makes a good final report?
- Coordination between investigation and legal assessment: if internal audit investigates and lawyers assess, the two must talk before the report is finalised. Otherwise the report sets the wrong priorities. This means proper coordination, not adjusting the result.
- Understandability: authorities and labour courts, including lay judges, often do not know the business. Technical jargon and anglicisms do harm.
- Executive summary: long reports are rarely read in full. A brief summary of the main findings at the beginning is indispensable.
- Feedback to the whistleblower: if the impetus came through a reporting channel, the person who made the report must be informed of the follow-up measures taken within three months (section 17(2) HinSchG). (Section 17 (2) of the HinSchG)
- Consider rights of access: data subjects may request information about their personal data under Art. 15 GDPR. On 16 April 2026, the BAG rejected a claim to a copy of the entire compliance report (8 AZR 169/25); details are in the article “Art. 15 GDPR: right of access in compliance reports”. (Art. 15 GDPR: Right to information in compliance reports)
Phase 4: Why follow-up is often forgotten
Many companies stop at the individual case: the consequence for the person involved is drawn, but the systemic cause remains. Then the incident repeats itself. It is more effective to concentrate on a few key findings and to set a responsible person and a date for each remedial measure. After later court, criminal or regulatory fine proceedings have concluded, a second review is worthwhile, because new findings often emerge there.
Checklist for internal investigations
- Document the report and start the investigation without delay.
- Define the goal, hypotheses and intended decision in writing.
- Compose the team according to the allegation and the need for confidentiality; secure IT access.
- Document the data protection pre-assessment before every data backup.
- Involve the works council and the insurer appropriately.
- Examine incriminating and exonerating circumstances equally; hear those affected.
- Steer regularly: team, effort, readiness for a decision.
- Prepare a short, understandable report with an executive summary.
- Keep notice periods and the consultation of the works council in view.
- Implement remedial measures with those responsible and review them later.
Frequently Asked Questions on Internal Investigations
Does the two-week period start when the internal investigation starts?
No. The period begins only when the party entitled to dismiss knows the relevant facts. As long as the fact-finding is pursued promptly, the start of the period is suspended.
May the employer analyse employees’ emails?
Only in compliance with data protection law. A documented reason, a clear purpose and a proportionality test are required. If private use is permitted or tolerated, stricter requirements apply.
Must the works council be involved in an internal investigation?
This depends on the measures and is partly disputed. Before a dismissal, the works council must in any case be consulted under section 102 BetrVG. Early confidential information of the chair is often sensible.
As the person accused, must I be heard before a dismissal?
Before a dismissal on suspicion, yes. The employer must hear you on the specific allegations and follow up exonerating leads. If the hearing is missing, a dismissal on suspicion is as a rule ineffective.
Conclusion: Structure beats actionism
Internal investigations rarely fail for lack of technical expertise, but because of organisation and communication. An early start, clear objectives, a review of data protection requirements and an open-minded investigation can support fact-finding. Whether the results are admissible in court depends on the individual case. The most important quality of everyone involved remains professional distance.
Do you need to follow up a report, or are you yourself affected by an investigation? Kanzlei Osuji supports companies in internal investigations and advises executives who are being investigated. The introductory call helps clarify your situation and does not include a document review. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. Employment law for employers · Advice for executives · Request an introductory call.
Author: Noah Osuji, attorney. As of 8 November 2026. This post provides general information and does not replace individual legal advice. The cover image is an AI-generated icon graphic.
Has a report of misconduct landed on your desk? For a summary dismissal, the two-week period runs from the date the employer gains knowledge. How investigations affect the time limit.
Sources and additional literature
- BGH, judgment of 21 April 1997, II ZR 175/95 (ARAG/Garmenbeck)
- BAG, judgment of 16 April 2026, 8 AZR 169/25 (information on compliance reports)
- Laws: § 626 BGB, § 26 BDSG, § 102 BetrVG, § 17 HinSchG (Section 26 BDSG · Section 102 BetrVG · Section 17 of the HinSchG)
