Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Employment law

D&O insurance and employee liability: who bears the loss after CEO impersonation fraud?

For work-related activities, the employee is liable according to graded principles; the employer must prove fault.

Read the German original

A person using a laptop with an email inbox open, beside a desk phone.
This image is AI-generated.

Employees are liable for damage caused in the course of work-related activities only according to graded principles. The Regional Labour Court Cologne refused this liability relief after CEO fraud because the employer had covered the risk through D&O insurance. This is not final: an appeal on points of law to the Federal Labour Court is pending, so the legal question has not been conclusively clarified.

When is an employee liable for damage in the company?

Limited employee liability applies to work-related activities. An activity is work-related if it was assigned to the employee, or is in the employer’s interest and closely connected with the business; releasing payments typically falls into this category. In cases of the slightest negligence, the employee is not liable. In cases of medium negligence, the damage is as a rule apportioned. In cases of gross negligence, the employee is as a rule fully liable; relief may be considered if earnings are clearly out of proportion to the risk of damage. In cases of intent, the employee is fully liable. The weighing takes into account, among other things, the amount of the damage, the employee’s position and earnings, and a risk that the employer factored in or that could be covered by insurance.

Managing directors and members of a management board have their own liability rules (§ 43 GmbHG, § 93 AktG). For them, the existence of the policy and its run-off cover matter, as the article termination agreement for managing directors shows.

Who has to prove fault?

The employer. Under § 619a BGB, the employer bears the burden of presenting and proving that the employee is responsible for the breach of duty. Unlike elsewhere in the law of obligations, fault is therefore not presumed. In fraud cases involving professionally forged instructions in particular, it matters what the employee could recognise and what controls were in place.

What did the LAG Cologne decide on CEO fraud?

In the proceedings (LAG Köln, judgment of 31 July 2026 – 8 SLa 603/25), the head of the treasury department had fallen victim to CEO fraud. Within 25 days, around 60 transfers with a total volume of more than 50 million euros were initiated. The court held the summary dismissal to be effective and did not apply the principles of limited employee liability in the employee’s favour. It reasoned that the employer had covered the risk through D&O insurance.

Whether this approach will hold is open. Whether a D&O policy shifts the liability weighing also depends on whom it protects at all and what exclusions it contains. Whether CEO fraud falls under the D&O policy or rather concerns a fidelity insurance policy must be clarified case by case.

What role does the D&O insurance play for liability?

D&O insurance primarily protects members of corporate bodies, and in some policies also senior executives or other employees, against claims for breach of duty. The policyholder is as a rule the company. This matters for employee liability for two reasons: the liability weighing takes into account whether a risk was insurable, and the question arises whether the employees themselves are covered by the insurance. Both depend on the specific terms, for example the co-insured persons, the exclusions and the deductible.

What should companies and employees consider in practice?

For companies:

  • Check the D&O terms: co-insured persons, exclusions, deductible and clauses that refer to employee liability.
  • Do not base payment releases on instructions by e-mail or telephone alone, but combine them with technical controls: four-eyes principle, callback to a known number, limits.
  • Document instructions and training so that it can be traced in a dispute what was required.

For executives and employees:

  • Clarify whether and to what extent you are co-insured yourself, and ask to be shown the terms.
  • Take warnings and control steps seriously, even under time pressure or with instructions from the very top.
  • Record unusual instructions and queries, for example through saved e-mails and notes.
  • Do not accept a dismissal without having it checked: the time limit for bringing a claim is three weeks from receipt (§ 4 KSchG).
  • If you are accused of causing damage, do not sign an acknowledgement of liability or a termination agreement until the situation has been reviewed. On removal from office and dismissal at managing director level, see Dismissing a managing director.

Frequently asked questions

Is an employee liable for full damages if they fall prey to a CEO fraud?

Not without more. Under the principles of limited employee liability, the extent depends on the degree of fault, and the employer must prove that the employee is responsible (§ 619a BGB). In the case of gross negligence, the employee is as a rule fully liable, but relief is possible where there is a clear disproportion between earnings and the risk of damage. The LAG Cologne’s decision shows that existing D&O insurance can play a role here.

Does the decision of the LAG Cologne already apply nationwide?

No. It is the judgment of a regional labour court, against which an appeal on points of law to the Federal Labour Court is pending. Whether the Federal Labour Court will assess the liability relief in the same way where D&O insurance exists is open.

How can a company prevent CEO fraud?

Payment releases should not depend on instructions by e-mail or telephone alone. The four-eyes principle, a callback to a known number and technical limits make sense, as do training and a clear rule for handling unusual instructions.

I advise companies on contract and insurance questions, more on this under Employment law for employers and SMEs, as well as executives and employees facing liability claims, more on this under Employment law for executives and managing directors. Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, in English on request.

For context: Employment law for executives and managing directors, with occasions and process. Also important: Termination of managing director: Pitfalls and termination agreement for managing directors. (Employment law for executives and managing directors)

Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.

Next step

The introductory call clarifies your enquiry and the possible scope of work. It does not include a document review. We agree the scope and fees before you instruct me.

This article is for general information and does not replace legal advice in individual cases. As at November 2026.

Noah Osuji

I am a lawyer in Munich and I advise on employment law, data protection law as well as IT and AI law – in German and English.

Back to Blog

More on advice at management level: Employment law for executives and managing directors.