Employment law
Bonuses and missed targets: what happens when an employer sets targets late or not at all?
If the employer does not communicate the bonus targets in time, the employee may claim damages equal to the lost bonus once the target period has ended.

If the employer does not set the bonus targets in time, the employee may claim damages equal to the lost bonus once the target period has ended. In 2026, the Federal Labour Court confirmed this for targets that were set internally but never communicated, and as a rule assumed 100% target achievement. Under the decision, the fact that the company missed its own targets does not change this.
Target agreement or target setting: what is the difference?
With a target agreement, employer and employee set the targets jointly. With target setting, the employer determines them unilaterally and exercises a right to determine performance at reasonable discretion (section 315 BGB). The employer must declare this determination to the employee (section 315(2) BGB). Setting targets internally only is not enough, because targets are meant to give orientation and to motivate, and that requires the employee to know them during the year. The basis may be the employment contract, a works agreement or a bonus policy.
What did the Federal Labour Court decide in the bonus case?
The subject of BAG, judgment of 22 April 2026 – 10 AZR 28/25 was the case of an employee working as Finance Manager. Her employment contract provided for a bonus of 15% of her gross annual income. The employer had set the company targets for 2022 internally but announced them to the employees only after the end of the year. 49% of the target bonus of around 16,350 euros was paid. The lower courts had dismissed the claim. The Federal Labour Court awarded the employee the difference of 8,339.40 euros gross as damages, that is about 51% of the target bonus. The decision continues BAG, judgment of 19 February 2025 – 10 AZR 57/24.
How does the court justify the damages?
- Breach of duty: Anyone who must set targets and does not communicate them breaches a contractual duty. Fault is presumed; the employer must show that it was not at fault.
- Damages instead of target setting: Once the target period has ended, the target setting can no longer be made up. Compensation for lost profit takes its place (section 280(1) and (3), section 283 sentence 1, section 252 BGB). (Section 280 (1) · Section 283, sentence 1)
- Amount: It is estimated (section 287 ZPO). It is to be assumed that the employee would have achieved the targets, unless the employer sets out and proves special circumstances. A poor economic year was not enough, because it was not apparent that the targets were achievable when they were set.
- Lawful alternative conduct: Anyone who objects that the loss would have occurred even if the targets had been communicated in time bears the burden of presenting and proving this. A mere possibility is not enough.
- No contributory fault: The employee does not have to demand the targets. The initiative lies with the employer.
Does the same apply to a target agreement?
Broadly, yes. Where the parties failed to reach a target agreement, the Federal Labour Court applies the same principles. They apply to the burden of presenting and proving the facts and to estimating damages. Whether and to what extent those principles help in an individual case depends on who was responsible for the failure to agree.
What should employers and employees bear in mind?
For employers:
- Communicate targets in writing or in text form at the start of the period and document receipt.
- Choose targets that are achievable on a forecast made when they are set, and keep a record of the forecast.
- Provide for adjustment clauses for sharp economic fluctuations and inform employees when an adjustment is made.
- Review the bonus policy or works agreement: who communicates what, and by when?
For the employees:
- Review the employment contract, bonus policy and works agreement, and record whether and when targets were communicated.
- Document the missing communication and keep correspondence. Asking is permitted but not a requirement.
- Keep contractual exclusion periods and the limitation period in mind, and assert claims in good time.
- With a termination agreement, regulate the bonus for the current and the last year expressly. On release from duties, see release from duties in a termination agreement.
- Other pay clauses can also be invalid without the matter being settled in the employer’s favour, as the English-language article Inflation-indexed pay clause in Germany shows.
- For managing directors, the profit-share bonus (Tantieme) depends on the service agreement. On removal from office and dismissal, see Dismissing a managing director.
Frequently asked questions
Am I entitled to the bonus if the company has missed its goals?
Not automatically. However, if it has been agreed that the employer sets targets and the employer culpably failed to do so, a claim for damages equal to the lost bonus may exist once the target period has ended. In that case, the Federal Labour Court as a rule assumes 100% target achievement if the employer does not set out and prove special circumstances. Missing the company targets does not necessarily rule out the claim.
As an employee, do I have to demand the goals?
Not according to the Federal Labour Court’s decision. The initiative lies with the employer; anyone who does not demand the targets does not have to accept contributory fault that reduces the claim. It can still be sensible to ask and to document the missing communication.
Is it enough if the employer has set the goals internally?
No. With target setting, the employer must declare the targets to the employee (section 315(2) BGB). A purely internal determination does not serve the purpose of target setting, which is to give orientation and motivation.
I review bonus and target arrangements, termination agreements and releases from duties, and I advise companies as well as executives. Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, in English on request. (Employment law for executives and managing directors)
Before signing: have a termination agreement reviewed, with process and costs. Also important: release from duties in a termination agreement, Inflation-indexed pay clause in Germany (in English) and Dismissing managing directors: pitfalls. (Have a termination agreement reviewed)
Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.
When the employment relationship ends, there is the additional question of which bonus may still be due after a dismissal. (Which bonus may still be due after a dismissal)
This article is for general information and does not replace legal advice in individual cases. Position as of November 2026.
More on advice at management level: Employment law for executives and managing directors.
