Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Data protection law

GDPR damages for loss of control: when a misdirected message can give rise to a claim

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) upholds the claim for damages as to liability and refers the case back to the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court (OLG) on the amount. No amount has been fixed yet.

Read the German original

A hand using a tablet beside a cup of coffee on a table.
This image is AI-generated.

Further reading: GDPR right of access for managing directors and board members, internal emails, compliance reports and the limits of Article 15 GDPR. (GDPR right to information for managing director and board members)

On GDPR damages for loss of control, the BGH holds the following: if a personal message is sent to a third party by mistake, and the third party takes note of it and uses it as an occasion for a follow-up question, there is compensable non-material damage under Article 82(1) GDPR (BGH, judgment of 23 June 2026, VI ZR 97/22).

Contents

  1. The case: A Xing message sent to the wrong recipient
  2. GDPR damages for loss of control: the CJEU’s benchmarks
  3. Why the BGH affirms the damage
  4. Practical implications for those affected
  5. Practical implications for companies
  6. Frequently asked questions

The case: A Xing message sent to the wrong recipient

An applicant was in an application process with a private bank that ran through Xing. On 23 October 2018, an employee of the bank sent a message intended only for the applicant, via the portal’s messenger service, to a third person as well, who was not involved in the process.

The content of the message is decisive for the legal assessment. It contained the applicant’s surname, his gender (evident from the form of address), the fact that the application process was ongoing, the bank’s attitude to his application and, indirectly, through the counter-offer of EUR 80,000 plus variable pay, the order of magnitude of his salary expectations.

The third party knew the applicant from earlier joint work at the same holding company. He forwarded the message and asked whether the applicant was looking for a job.

The job applicant sought an injunction and at least €2,500 in non-material damages. Darmstadt Regional Court awarded €1,000 and granted the injunction. Frankfurt Higher Regional Court set aside the damages award because the claimant had not shown specific harm, but upheld the injunction. The Federal Court of Justice stayed the proceedings. It referred questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (C-655/23, judgment of 4 September 2025). Following that preliminary ruling, the Federal Court of Justice reached its decision: the claimant was entitled to damages but not to an injunction.

GDPR damages for loss of control: the CJEU’s benchmarks

The BGH summarises the established CJEU case law in four propositions that are worth remembering:

PrincipleMeaning
Autonomous interpretationThe concept of non-material damage is not governed by national law but must be determined under EU law and, according to recital 146, interpreted broadly.
No breach automatismA mere GDPR breach is not sufficient. The occurrence of damage is an independent condition of the claim.
No materiality thresholdA national practice that requires a certain degree of seriousness is contrary to EU law; even minor damage is compensable.
Burden of proof remainsThe removal of the materiality threshold does not dispense with the need to prove that the negative consequences amount to non-material damage.

Two groups of cases are recognised:

Loss of control. According to recital 85, loss of control over one’s own data is among the possible types of damage. The CJEU states that even a short-term loss of control may constitute non-material damage, provided that the data subject proves that they actually suffered such damage, however minor it may be.

Well-founded fear of misuse. The fear that data could be misused may in itself constitute non-material damage, provided that it is duly proven together with its negative consequences. The mere assertion of a fear without proven consequences is not sufficient, nor is a purely hypothetical risk. The fear must be capable of being regarded as well-founded in the particular circumstances.

Remarkable and of practical significance: the compensable negative consequences may also include worry and annoyance, even where such feelings may be part of the general risk of life. In addition, actual misuse is required in neither group of cases.

Why the BGH affirms the damage

The BGH bases its decision on two considerations, which it cites cumulatively (“on the one hand … on the other”).

First, the loss of control was not without consequences. The third party took note of the data and used it as an occasion to contact the claimant. According to the BGH, that already amounts to misuse. The Senate states unusually clearly that the CJEU case law shows “without doubt” that, in any case, non-material damage exists in such a situation.

Secondly, the fear was well-founded. The claimant feared that the third party, who worked in the same industry, might have passed on the information or, as a competitor, gained an advantage in the application process. The fact that the third party actually enquired about the application made this fear sufficiently well-founded.

The point in time is precisely defined: the damage exists at the latest from the moment the third party took note of the data and used it as the occasion for the enquiry, not already when the message was sent.

A detail that weakens the line of defence of many companies: the bank had disputed that the claimant was identifiable. The BGH rejects this, referring to the CJEU (C-479/22). The fact that additional information may be needed for identification does not preclude classification as personal data. And the data subject does not have to prove that they were actually identified.

Important for expectations: the BGH decided only as to liability. Under § 287 ZPO, the assessment is reserved to the trial court, and the case was referred back to the OLG Frankfurt. The EUR 1,000 awarded at first instance is no precedent.

Practical implications for those affected

  1. Do not stop at the breach. The breach alone does not support the claim. What followed from it must be set out.
  2. Document that the third party took note of the data. The turning point in the decided case was the third party’s follow-up question. Preserve chat histories, emails and screenshots.
  3. Give concrete reasons for the fear. General worry is not enough. What was sufficient here: same industry, competitive situation, possible passing on.
  4. Choose the application for an injunction deliberately. An application limited to the specific form of infringement fails if the situation cannot recur. Anyone who wants to attack the organisational susceptibility to error must word the application accordingly, and then bears the risk of lack of definiteness.
  5. Consider the costs consequences. By losing on the injunction, the claimant also lost the claim to reimbursement of the pre-litigation legal costs attributable to it.

Practical implications for companies

The decision moves the liability risk into everyday business. A single sending error, not a hacker attack and not a systematic data leak, is enough for a claim as to liability.

Organisational: Messenger services of career portals are structurally risky for confidential communication, because the choice of recipient and the message history come together in one interface. Salary data and rejection decisions belong in a channel with send control.

Procedural: Disputing identifiability rarely succeeds. Not all the information needs to be in one hand, and the data subject does not have to prove their actual identification.

In responding: A cease-and-desist undertaking that refers only to the wording of the message complained of is evidently narrow. The BGH left open whether it suffices, so one should not rely on that question.

On the notification duty: The BGH was able to leave open whether there was also a breach of Article 34 GDPR, because the claimant did not derive any separate damage from it. That is no relief: in other situations, a failure to notify may give rise to a separate head of damage.

Frequently asked questions

Is one GDPR breach enough for damages?

No. The occurrence of damage is an independent condition of the claim. It must be proven that the breach actually led to damage.

Is the mere loss of control compensable damage?

It can be. The CJEU expressly counts loss of control over personal data among the possible types of damage, even where the loss is only short-term. The data subject must, however, prove that they actually suffered such damage.

Must actual misuse have taken place?

No. Actual misuse is required neither for loss of control nor for well-founded fear.

How much damages are awarded for a misdirected message?

That has not yet been fixed in case VI ZR 97/22. The BGH decided only as to liability and referred the assessment back to the OLG Frankfurt. The trial court determines the amount under § 287 ZPO.

Is there also a claim for an injunction alongside damages?

The GDPR itself does not provide for a preventive remedy by way of an injunction without a request for erasure. National claims under section 1004(1) sentence 2 BGB by analogy remain possible, but require a risk of repetition. (§ 1004 para. 1 sentence 2)

Does the risk of repetition cease if the occasion has fallen away?

It may. The presumption of a risk of repetition can be rebutted if the infringement was triggered by a one-off special situation, for example a completed application process.

Conclusion

The judgment consistently separates two claims that are often asserted together in practice: a past data protection breach may give rise to liability for compensation without there being a risk of repetition. For legal practice, the real lesson lies in the wording of the application. The claimant failed for lack of a risk of repetition, and this fell away because his application described a situation that could not recur once the application process had ended.

Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: 13 August 2026. The article does not replace advice in individual cases.

Next step

The introductory call clarifies your enquiry and the possible scope of work. It does not include a document review. We agree the scope and fees before you instruct me.

This article is for general information and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. As of 13 August 2026.

Noah Osuji

I am a lawyer in Munich and advise on employment law, data protection law and IT and AI law, in German and English.

Back to Blog

More about my advice in data protection law and employee data protection.