Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

IT & AI Law

Fictitious judgments in court submissions: the Federal Labour Court on a lawyer’s duty to check citations

The Federal Labour Court (BAG) dismissed a complaint against the refusal of leave to appeal as inadmissible, because the decisions cited indicated that the lawyer representing the party had not checked the grounds himself.

Read the German original

A hand holding a magnifying glass over documents beside a Lady Justice figure and a laptop.
This image is AI-generated.

If a lawyer files a court submission containing invented judgments, this may have not only professional consequences but also affect the proceedings themselves. The Federal Labour Court dismissed a complaint against the refusal of leave to appeal as inadmissible, because the decisions cited indicated that the lawyer representing the party had not checked the grounds himself (BAG, decision of 30 September 2026, 2 AZN 339/26). Responsibility for the result cannot be handed over to a tool.

What has the Federal Labour Court decided?

The claimant lodged a complaint against refusal of leave to appeal against the judgment of the Baden-Württemberg Regional Labour Court, which had not granted leave to appeal on points of law (judgment of 15 May 2026, 7 Sa 17/26). The grounds had been signed by her lawyer and sent via the special electronic mailbox for lawyers (beA). Unlike his other submissions, however, they bore no firm letterhead, were formatted unusually and contained unusual wording. Four of the decisions cited did not exist, and three others were reproduced incorrectly.

The BAG spoke of “hallucinations”, took the incorrect citations as an indication that the lawyer had not checked the submission himself, and referred to the guidance of the Federal Bar Association (BRAK) on the use of AI. The lawyer’s later statement that he took responsibility came only after the time limit for the grounds had expired and was disregarded.

Why does a misquotation make the complaint inadmissible?

Before the Federal Labour Court, the parties must be represented by authorised representatives (section 11(4) sentence 1 ArbGG). Without effective representation, the procedural act is ineffective. The lawyer does not have to have written the submission himself, but he must review it independently and take full responsibility for it; in principle, a signature is sufficient for that. The position is different if the external circumstances leave no doubt that it was signed without the lawyer’s own review. The BAG assumed that here. The decisive factor was therefore not the use of a tool, but the lack of control by the lawyer. (Section 11(4), first sentence)

How have other courts reacted to invented citations?

Other courts have also criticised invented citations, in some cases pointing to professional duties. In those decisions, the matter remained at comments on professional conduct; the procedural act itself was not held to be ineffective. Breaches of professional rules are pursued by the regional bar associations. At the BAG, however, the defect affected the proceedings directly because of the requirement of representation by a lawyer.

What does professional law require when using AI?

Section 43, sentence 1 BRAO requires lawyers to practise their profession conscientiously. Under section 43a(3) BRAO, a lawyer must not behave unobjectively; this includes in particular the deliberate dissemination of untruths. Anyone who adopts citations unchecked out of carelessness does not necessarily spread them deliberately, but touches on the requirement of conscientiousness. (Section 43, sentence 1 · Section 43a (3))

In its “Guidance on the use of artificial intelligence (AI)” (as of December 2024), the BRAK requires independent review and final checking of AI results. AI is intended to support the work of lawyers, not to replace it. In its opinion no. 32/2025, the German Bar Association (DAV) considers a complete check of the supporting references to be necessary. There are no binding special rules for the use of AI by lawyers.

What remains open above all is how far work results may be based on AI without jeopardising insurance cover. In the DAV’s view, the check may be omitted if the client expressly wishes to use an AI result unchecked as a working basis. This is not risk-free: from a certain degree of automation, it may be questionable whether legal work is still being carried out and whether the professional liability insurance provides cover. That is still open.

What does this mean for companies and legal departments?

The represented party shares the risk: in the case decided, the appeal was lost. Those who use AI or instruct law firms can take countermeasures early:

  • Questions for the law firm: Is AI used, for what purpose, and who checks citations and references before they are sent? This can be recorded in the engagement.
  • Own AI policy: Determine which tools are permitted for which purposes and which data must not be entered. If personal data reaches third parties in an uncontrolled way, the loss of control alone can give rise to damages under the GDPR. (GDPR damages for loss of control)
  • In-house approval: Expert opinions and court submissions from the legal department also need a named person who checks the result and takes responsibility for it.
  • Waive the check only deliberately: Anyone who expressly waives it should know the open questions on liability and insurance cover.
  • Time limits: Allow time for the check, because accepting responsibility after the time limit has expired does not help. Many time limits in employment law are tight, for example the time limit of three weeks after receipt of a dismissal for bringing a claim (claim for protection against dismissal in Munich).

How can court submissions and expert opinions be safeguarded?

  1. Check citations against the original: Look up the court, date and file reference in the decision itself, not just in an AI answer.
  2. Compare quotations: Does the decision support the statement for which it is cited? Check verbatim quotations and paragraph numbers against the full text.
  3. Treat AI results as drafts: Legal assessment and argumentation remain your own work. Unusual wording is a reason to read the text through again in full.
  4. Document responsibility: Record internally who checked which citations and when, and who approved the text.

Frequently asked questions

Can a lawyer use AI for briefs?

There is no ban. The BRAK sees AI as a support and requires independent review and final checking. In the BAG case, the problem was not the use of AI but the lack of review by the lawyer representing the party.

What can clients do to reduce the risk?

Clients can ask whether and for what purpose the law firm uses AI, who checks the citations and how confidentiality is preserved. Within the firm itself, a policy should regulate which AI tools may be used.

Does the requirement of legal representation also apply before the labour court?

The requirement of representation under section 11(4) ArbGG applies before the Federal Labour Court and the regional labour courts. At first instance before the labour court, the parties may conduct the proceedings themselves. The professional duties of an instructed lawyer apply irrespective of the court.

I advise companies on AI policies, contracts with AI providers and the legal framework in day-to-day operations. More on this under IT, SaaS and AI law. Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, in English too if you wish.

For an overview, see Employment law in Munich, with all areas of focus. On time limits and proof in employment law, see the article on registered post dropped into the letterbox and receipt of a dismissal. (Delivery of a dismissal letter by registered post)

Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.

Next step

The introductory call clarifies your enquiry and the possible scope of work. It does not include a document review. We agree the scope and fees before you instruct me.

This article is for general information and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. As of November 2026.

Noah Osuji

I am a lawyer in Munich and advise on employment law, data protection law and IT and AI law, in German and English.

Back to Blog

More about consulting: IT, SaaS and AI law for companies. (IT, SaaS and AI law for enterprises)