Employment law Employers
Reporting concerns to the supervisory board: when can summary dismissal be lawful?
A direct message to the supervisory board is not automatically a protected report or a permissible breach of duty.

Anyone who reports misconduct directly to the supervisory board is moving between freedom of expression, possible whistleblower protection and contractual duties of loyalty. A decision of the European Court of Human Rights of January 2026 illustrates which circumstances can justify a summary dismissal.
Can an employee report misconduct directly to the supervisory board?
There is no blanket answer. Employees may voice justified criticism and, under statutory conditions, report violations of the law. At the same time, duties of consideration, confidentiality and loyalty apply. Whether a prescribed reporting channel has to be followed depends on the context. For its scope of application, the Whistleblower Protection Act regulates reporting procedures and protection against reprisals; not every internal complaint falls under it.
What did the European Court of Human Rights decide in 2026?
In a decision of 13 January 2026 (application no. 32135/23), the European Court of Human Rights dealt with a summary dismissal following a message to members of the supervisory board. The person concerned had bypassed internal superiors and sent out information about business transactions. In the particular circumstances of the case, the national courts regarded this as a serious breach of the duty of loyalty.
The ECtHR did see an interference with freedom of expression under Art. 10 ECHR, but regarded the balancing as tenable in the specific circumstances. Relevant factors included the aim of the communication, good faith, alternatives to escalation, protection of confidentiality and the severity of the sanction. (Art. 10 ECHR)
Why is this not a general ban on whistleblowing?
The decision does not mean that employees always risk their job when reporting to a supervisory body, or that they must first involve their superiors. Statutory reporting rights and the protection of justified whistleblowers must still be observed. In the case decided, the good faith of the person concerned was denied in particular, and a predominant purpose of exerting personal pressure was found.
Companies must not undermine legally protected reports through general loyalty clauses. Equally, merely calling a message “whistleblowing” does not justify passing on any confidential information.
What should employers and employees consider?
- Clearly communicate internal and external reporting channels and responsibilities.
- Ensure confidentiality and protection of identity to the extent required by law.
- In the event of conflict, document specifically what the alleged violation of the law or breach of duty consists of.
- Before a dismissal, examine the milder measure, proportionality and any prohibitions on reprisals.
- Do not send confidential details unnecessarily to broad distribution lists.
In the case of disputed dismissals, a prompt review of the protection against dismissal is advisable. For companies: (Review of dismissal protection · Employment law advice for employers)
Frequently asked questions
Can I contact the supervisory board directly?
This may be permissible. Whether the specific route is protected depends on the subject matter, the legal position and the circumstances; there is no general duty to report to superiors.
Is a summary dismissal because of an email automatically effective?
No. In particular, there must be good cause and a comprehensive balancing of interests under section 626 BGB.
Would you like to have a specific case reviewed? Contact Kanzlei Osuji in Munich or +49 174 343 0142. (Contact Kanzlei Osuji in Munich)
As of: 6 November 2026. Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer. General information, not advice on an individual case. AI-generated symbolic image; it does not depict any actual participants in the proceedings.
For advice on your situation: Employment advice for employers and HR.
