Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Annual leave

Annual leave during long-term illness: when a contract clause prevents lapse after 15 months

If an employee is ill without interruption, their statutory annual leave generally lapses 15 months after the end of the leave year.

Read the German original

Packed suitcase beside an empty chair, a wall calendar and a houseplant by the window.
This image is AI-generated.

In short: annual leave can survive even years of illness if the employment contract provides for this. Fifteen months is the shortest carry-over period that EU law allows before leave lapses during illness. It does not follow that leave must lapse once that period has expired. A more favourable clause in the employment contract takes precedence.

When does annual leave lapse during long-term illness?

Under the Federal Leave Act (BUrlG), leave must be granted and taken in the current calendar year. It may be carried over to the following year only for urgent operational or personal reasons, and must then be taken by the end of March (section 7(3) BUrlG).

This rule does not apply unchanged to employees who cannot take leave because of illness. According to the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, their statutory minimum leave must not lapse after only three months. The Federal Labour Court therefore interprets section 7(3) BUrlG in line with EU law: if an employee has been unable to work without interruption since the start of the leave year, their statutory leave lapses at the end of 31 March of the second following year – 15 months after the end of the leave year. For leave from 2024, that date was 31 March 2026. In this situation it does not matter whether the employer gave notice about the leave.

The position is different if the employee worked for part of the leave year before falling ill. It then depends on whether the employer informed them in good time about the outstanding leave and the risk of it lapsing. Without that notice, leave from that year does not simply lapse even after 15 months.

All of this concerns the statutory minimum leave. For additional contractual leave, employers and employees can agree their own lapse rules, provided the contract clearly distinguishes between the two.

What was case 9 AZR 198/24 about?

The claimant worked as a nurse for a Protestant welfare organisation. Her employment contract referred to the employment guidelines of the Diakonisches Werk of the Protestant Church in Germany, now known as AVR-DD. These guidelines limited the carry-over of leave during illness to deadlines in the following year, at the latest 30 September.

The employment contract also contained its own leave clause. Under it, leave generally had to be taken by 30 April of the following year. If the employee could not take it by then because of illness certified by a doctor, the entitlement was to continue, limited to the outstanding statutory leave. The clause did not set an end date. Another clause provided that such leave was to be paid in lieu when the employment ended.

The nurse was unable to work without interruption from 31 July 2015 until her employment ended on 30 June 2023. She then claimed payment in lieu of her statutory minimum leave for the years 2016 to 2021. The employer argued that this leave had lapsed 15 months after the end of each leave year. The labour court dismissed the claim; the Düsseldorf Regional Labour Court allowed it (judgment of 28 May 2024 – 8 SLa 49/24).

How did the Federal Labour Court decide?

On 15 July 2025 the Federal Labour Court dismissed the employer's appeal on points of law. The nurse receives payment in lieu of 144 working days of statutory minimum leave, which according to the judgment amounts to EUR 16,908.92 gross. The reasoning can be summarised in three steps:

  1. The church guideline was partly void. To the extent that it let the statutory minimum leave of employees who were ill lapse before 15 months had passed, it breached the Federal Leave Act. In that respect it was replaced by section 7(3) BUrlG as interpreted in line with EU law, i.e. lapse after 15 months.
  2. EU law does not require leave to lapse. Article 7 of the Working Time Directive 2003/88/EC does not require leave to be lost after 15 months of long illness. It permits national rules that provide for this. Rules in employment contracts or collective agreements that are more favourable to employees remain permissible.
  3. The contractual clause took precedence. The court interpreted the leave clause as an independent and exhaustive rule that excludes lapse during long illness. There was no room for supplementary application of the lapse rules in the church guidelines. The leave therefore continued until the end of the employment and had to be paid in lieu (section 7(4) BUrlG).

The fact that the contract also referred to the church employment guidelines did not change this. According to the court, the contract itself showed a deliberate departure: it provided for earlier lapse outside long illness overall and contained a payment-in-lieu rule that the guidelines do not have. The church's right to self-determination did not stand in the way of the clause either. The court saw no need to refer the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

What does the judgment mean for employers?

The risk lies in how contracts are drafted. Long illnesses are rare but expensive: with a carry-over clause without a time limit, every further year of illness builds up leave that must be paid in lieu when the employee leaves.

  • Align references and own clauses. Employers who refer to a collective agreement or church employment guidelines and also write their own leave rules into the contract should know which rule prevails in a conflict. A contractual rule that is more favourable to employees can take precedence.
  • Draft carry-over periods deliberately. If leave during illness should not be preserved for longer than legally required, the clause must not provide for indefinite continuation. A period shorter than 15 months is invalid for the statutory minimum leave.
  • Regulate additional leave separately. Separate lapse rules are possible for additional contractual leave if the contract clearly distinguishes between statutory and additional leave.
  • Give notice. Employers should inform employees in good time, and in a way they can prove, about outstanding leave and the risk of it lapsing. For employees who fall ill during the year, lapse depends on it.

Review of contract templates and HR processes: Employment law for employers.

What should employees check after a long illness?

  1. Read the leave clause. The wording of the employment contract is decisive. If it provides for carry-over during illness without a time limit, the statutory leave survives beyond 15 months.
  2. Check the employer's notices. Anyone who worked for part of the leave year should check whether the employer informed them in good time about leave and lapse.
  3. Claim payment in lieu promptly. When the employment ends, outstanding leave becomes a payment claim. Time limits for claims in the employment contract or a collective agreement may apply to it. It should therefore be asserted in writing soon after leaving.
  4. Deal with outstanding leave in a termination agreement. How outstanding leave, payment in lieu and release from duties fit together is explained in Outstanding annual leave in a termination agreement.

Frequently asked questions about annual leave and long-term illness

Does my leave lapse if I am ill for more than a year?

In the case of uninterrupted illness, statutory leave generally lapses 15 months after the end of the leave year. If your employment contract or collective agreement provides for a longer or unlimited carry-over, that rule applies.

Will I be paid for my leave if I leave after a long illness?

Yes, to the extent that it still exists when the employment ends. It must then be paid in lieu. Time limits for claims in the employment contract or a collective agreement may restrict how long it can be asserted.

Can an employment contract shorten the lapse period to less than 15 months?

Not for the statutory minimum leave. Such a rule is invalid to that extent, and the 15-month period applies. Different rules are possible for additional contractual leave.

Does the judgment apply only to church employers?

No. The case concerned a Protestant welfare organisation, but the principle that a more favourable carry-over clause takes precedence over lapse after 15 months applies to every employment contract.

Conclusion: the 15 months are not automatic

The Federal Labour Court makes clear that lapse after 15 months is a permissible limit, not a mandatory one. An employer that agrees indefinite carry-over during illness in the employment contract must pay in lieu of the leave of long-term sick employees in the end – even for many years. Employers should align their leave clauses with references to collective agreements or employment guidelines. After a long illness, employees should read their employment contract before assuming that outstanding leave has lapsed.

Outstanding leave after a long illness, or a leave clause that needs reviewing? Kanzlei Osuji advises employees and employers. The introductory call helps clarify your situation and does not include a document review. We agree the scope of work and fees transparently before you instruct me. Request an introductory call.

Author: Noah Osuji, Rechtsanwalt (German lawyer). As of 10 November 2026. This article provides general information and does not replace individual legal advice.

Noah Osuji

I am a lawyer in Munich and I advise on employment law, data protection law as well as IT and AI law – in German and English.

Back to Blog

Next step

We agree the scope of work and fees before you instruct me.

Sources and status