Employment law
Non-compete clauses in employment contracts: what the rules actually cover
A post-contractual non-compete clause without a promise of non-compete compensation is void; even a severability clause does not cure this defect.

Many assumptions circulate about post-contractual non-compete clauses that are not correct. Some work against employers, others against employees. The following questions put them in context on the basis of §§ 74 ff. HGB, which also apply to employees via § 110 GewO. Anyone who knows them can draft a ban better or better assess whether it binds them.
Does the ban also apply without a promise of compensation?
No. A post-contractual non-compete clause requires a promise of non-compete compensation (section 74(2) HGB). If it is missing, the ban is void. The Federal Labour Court has clarified that even a severability clause does not cure this defect (BAG, judgment of 22 March 2017 – 10 AZR 448/15). The employee is then not bound, but cannot claim compensation either. For employers this means: anyone who forgets the promise has no enforceable ban, although they may believe it is secure. How high the compensation must be is shown in the article on non-compete compensation and costs. (Non-compete clause: non-compete compensation and costs)
Can the employer waive the ban at any time?
No. A waiver is possible only before the employment relationship ends, and only by written declaration. The obligation to pay ends only on expiry of one year after the declaration (section 75a HGB). Anyone who waives too late remains bound by the non-compete agreement and pays the compensation. In practice the decision is often made too late, because the notice period and release from duties shorten the time until departure. This matters for the employee too: a waiver is likely to release them from the ban, while the employer’s obligation to pay continues until the end of the year. (Section 75a HGB)
How long can a ban last at most?
Two assumptions are widespread: that “a maximum of one year” applies, or that the duration can be freely agreed. Neither is correct. The ban cannot apply for more than two years after the employment relationship ends (section 74a(1) HGB). There is no minimum duration. Even within the two years, the ban needs a legitimate interest of the employer. If it goes further or unfairly hinders the employee’s career, it is not binding to that extent. (Section 74a (1) HGB)
Is an oral agreement or an email enough?
No. The ban must be agreed in writing, and the employer must hand the employee a document signed by the employer containing the agreed provisions (section 74(1) HGB). An oral agreement or a mere email is as a rule not sufficient for this. Anyone who disregards the form risks that the ban cannot be enforced. This applies in particular to bans that are only added on a promotion, in a supplementary agreement or at the last minute in a termination agreement: they too need the written form and the document handed over.
Does the same apply to managing directors and management board members?
Not necessarily. Special rules apply to members of corporate bodies. Managing directors and management board members who have agreed, or are asked to agree, to a non-compete clause should therefore have the contract reviewed separately, ideally when it is concluded or, at the latest, when separation is being negotiated. More on this in the article on termination agreements for managing directors. (Termination agreement for managing directors)
What does this mean in practice?
- Employers: agree bans specifically and in writing, budget for compensation and decide on a waiver before the employee leaves.
- Executives: before signing, check compensation, duration and scope, and on separation clarify whether the ban continues.
- Both sides: also regulate the ban expressly in a termination agreement so that nothing remains open. This includes the question of whether it should continue, be shortened or be lifted.
Frequently asked questions
When should I have a non-compete clause reviewed?
Ideally before signing, and at the latest before a move or on separation. It can then still be clarified whether the ban regulates compensation, duration and scope clearly and whether it fits the planned new field of work.
Do I have to comply with a ban that goes too far?
A ban that goes beyond the employer’s legitimate interest or unfairly hinders the employee’s career is not binding to that extent (section 74a(1) HGB). How the employee should decide depends on the individual case. This should be clarified before a move.
What is the minimum that an employer must pay?
For each year of the ban, at least half of the last contractual benefits received (section 74(2) HGB). For the calculation and the offsetting of other earnings, see the article on non-compete compensation and costs.
I advise executives, employees and employers on post-contractual non-compete clauses, more at non-compete clauses in employment law in Munich. Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, also in English on request.
For context: Employment law in Munich, with all focus areas at a glance. Also important: non-compete compensation and the costs of a non-compete clause, and a termination agreement as a managing director. (Non-compete compensation and costs of a non-compete clause · Termination agreement for managing directors)
Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.
This article provides general information and does not replace legal advice in individual cases. Last updated: November 2026.
More on advice at executive level: Employment law for executives and managing directors.
