Employment law
Repayment of training costs: when an unclear clause is unenforceable
Repayment clauses for training costs are in principle possible, but are subject to review as General Terms and Conditions.

Employers who pay for training often want to retain employees for some time and reclaim the costs if they leave beforehand. Such repayment clauses are in principle possible, but often fail the review of General Terms and Conditions. In 2022 to 2025, the Federal Labour Court repeatedly declared clauses invalid (most recently BAG, 21.10.2025 – 9 AZR 266/24).
By what standard do courts examine repayment clauses?
Pre-formulated clauses are subject to content review under section 307(1) BGB. They are invalid if they unreasonably disadvantage the employee contrary to good faith or are not clear and understandable. Under section 305c(2) BGB, ambiguities are construed against the employer as the party using the clause. If a clause is invalid, it is void without replacement under section 306(1) BGB: the court does not reduce it to a permissible extent. (Section 307 (1) · Section 305c (2) · Section 306 (1))
What did the Federal Labour Court decide on resignation and examinations?
- 9 AZR 260/21 (judgment of 01.03.2022): The repayment obligation may not be tied across the board to every resignation by the employee. A comprehensive review is decisive; the clause was void without replacement.
- 9 AZR 187/22 (25.04.2023): A clause that tied repayment to repeated failure to take the examination, without differentiating, was invalid and void.
- 9 AZR 266/24 (21.10.2025): A geriatric nurse had resigned after training with a 24-month commitment period. The employer demanded pro rata repayment. The clause (“for reasons for which the employee is responsible”) was ambiguous; the ambiguity was construed against the employer. It was invalid insofar as it also covers resignation in the case of permanent inability to perform through no fault of the employee.
What role do binding duration and transparency play?
The commitment period should match the duration, cost and benefit of the training; the longer it runs, the more the question of reasonableness arises. At the same time, it must be clear to the employee when payment is due. A clause that leaves open which grounds for termination are covered risks failing. This also applies to wording that allows different interpretations: the party that puts forward the clause bears this risk. It therefore makes sense to distinguish by the reason for leaving, that is, resignation, dismissal by the employer and termination agreement.
Does the same apply to vocational training?
Not without more. For vocational training, section 12 BBiG contains its own rules: agreements that restrict the trainee after the end of the training are in principle void (exception: a promise of takeover made in the last six months); compensation for the training is also invalid. The provision does not directly regulate repayment clauses for further training; it serves here only for delimitation. (§ 12)
What should employers bear in mind when drafting?
- Agree before the start: The clause belongs in a written training agreement, concluded before the measure begins.
- Quantify costs: Name course fees and other reimbursable items individually.
- Tiering: Reduce the repayment amount step by step the longer the employee stays.
- Differentiate the triggers: Regulate the reasons for leaving separately and expressly name exceptions such as permanent inability to perform through no fault of the employee.
- Check existing templates: If a clause falls away, there is no repayment claim; it is worth looking at old contracts.
What should employees check before a termination?
Before giving notice, employees should read the training agreement: Which costs are named, how long does the commitment last, from when does the amount fall, and does the clause cover precisely this reason for leaving? They should not pay too hastily; validity can be checked, especially if the employer itself gives notice or a termination agreement is on the table. With a termination agreement, a settlement and release clause may also settle possible repayment claims (settlement and release clause in a termination agreement); you can have the contract checked before signing. (Have it checked before signing)
Frequently asked questions
Can the employer claim back training costs if I terminate?
In principle, this is possible if the clause has been validly agreed. It may not, however, be tied across the board to every resignation, and it must be clear and understandable (Federal Labour Court, 9 AZR 260/21).
Can a court reduce an invalid clause to a permissible extent?
No. In the cases decided by the BAG, an invalid clause is void without replacement (section 306(1) BGB). The employer then cannot reclaim anything.
Do the principles also apply to vocational training costs?
For vocational training, section 12 BBiG applies, which declares certain agreements void or invalid. Whether a clause is permissible depends on the individual case and should be reviewed separately.
I advise employers on drafting training agreements and employees on reviewing repayment demands (more on this under Employment law for employers). Before you instruct me, we agree the fee, in English if you wish.
For orientation: Employment law in Munich, with all focus areas at a glance. For executives: Employment law for executives and managing directors.
Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer, Kanzlei Osuji. As of: November 2026.
This article is for general information and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. As of November 2026.
More about advice: have a termination agreement reviewed in Munich. (Termination agreement review in Munich)
