Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Executives, bonuses and equity

Company car during garden leave, dismissal and illness: when must it be returned?

A company car that may also be used privately is regularly part of the pay package. Dismissal or garden leave therefore does not automatically end that entitlement. What matters is the company car agreement, any revocation clause and how it is applied in the specific case.

Car key and a closed document folder on a desk; a car is parked in front of the window.
This image is AI-generated.

Why private use is more than a work tool

A vehicle used exclusively for business is treated differently from a car you may also drive at weekends or on holiday. Agreed private use saves you your own mobility costs and is regularly part of the consideration for your work. Whether and to what extent it was promised follows in particular from the employment contract, the company car agreement and any car policy that was validly incorporated.

You should therefore look at more than the vehicle category. Your own contribution, fuel costs, authorised drivers, travel abroad, damage rules and the conditions for return are also relevant. A taxable benefit shown on the payslip is no substitute for a full review of your rights under the employment contract.

May the employer withdraw the company car during garden leave?

Unless a valid provision provides otherwise, the promised private use in principle continues for as long as remuneration is owed. Garden leave (release from duties) alone does not remove that entitlement. Where there is a revocation clause, two questions must be kept apart: is the clause valid, and was it exercised reasonably in the specific case?

On 12 February 2025 – 5 AZR 171/24 – the Federal Labour Court (BAG) accepted a clause that permitted revocation without compensation in the event of justified garden leave during the notice period. The assertion that withdrawal is only ever permissible against financial compensation would therefore go too far.

Even a valid clause, however, does not permit an arbitrary date of return. In the case decided, the car could only be withdrawn at the end of the month. The decisive factor was the month-by-month tax charge: the employee was in principle to be able to use the benefit that had been taxed for the whole month. The BAG therefore awarded compensation for the remaining part of the month.

For how garden leave as a whole should be regulated, see the article Release from duties in a termination agreement.

What applies during illness, maternity protection and parental leave?

During illness, the promised private use in principle remains in place for as long as the employer owes continued payment of remuneration. Once that period has ended, the duty to keep providing the car may also lapse, unless something more favourable has been agreed. The BAG confirmed this in its judgment of 14 December 2010 – 9 AZR 631/09. The decisive point is therefore not merely that the employment relationship continues.

Maternity protection and parental leave should not be equated. Special protective rules apply to maternity protection periods; where private use has been irrevocably promised, whether it continues must be considered separately. During parental leave without an entitlement to pay, by contrast, the same entitlement does not automatically exist as during paid employment. Part-time work during parental leave and more favourable contractual promises can change the assessment.

For the assessment, the exact type of absence, the period and the agreement are decisive. A blanket return rule “for any absence” does not reliably answer these questions.

Must I hand the car back as soon as I receive notice of dismissal?

In the case of dismissal with notice, the employment relationship ends only when the notice period has expired. Until then, what matters is the continuing duty to pay remuneration and any valid revocation. The car must be returned when the entitlement to use it actually ends.

A claim for protection against dismissal does not in itself give an unrestricted right to keep the vehicle beyond the alleged end of the contract. A claim to continued employment and the outcome of the proceedings may be relevant to further claims for use or compensation. Retaining the car should therefore be reviewed in advance.

In a termination agreement, the return date, continued private use or financial compensation can be agreed expressly. Record the mileage, condition, accessories and keys at handover. Signing a handover record should not unintentionally become a waiver of disputed claims.

When can compensation for loss of use be claimed?

If private use that is owed is unlawfully withdrawn, a claim for monetary compensation may arise. The amount depends on the basis of the claim and the facts. To value lost private use, case law draws on, among other things, the taxable value of use; reference is often made to one per cent of the relevant gross list price per month. Specific replacement expenditure is to be distinguished from this.

This does not mean that every return gives rise to a claim, or that all hire-car costs are automatically reimbursed. You should have the period, the calculation put forward, any own contribution and the contractual provisions reviewed. Keep statements of account, demands for return and the handover record, and observe cut-off periods.

Points for employees and employers to clarify

  • Is private use expressly promised, and which agreement applies?
  • What specific ground for revocation does the contract state?
  • Is the garden leave justified, and does it fall within the ground for revocation?
  • Does the return date fit the tax treatment and the parties’ interests?
  • Are a replacement car, compensation or an own contribution provided for?
  • Which claims should expressly be preserved in the termination agreement?

Employers should document the validity of the car policy and the decision in the individual case separately. Employees should have a demand for return reviewed promptly. For further components of pay on a separation, see Bonuses after notice of termination.

Frequently asked questions about returning a company car

Is a revocation always invalid if no compensation is paid?

No. A revocation without compensation can be validly agreed and validly exercised. The clause, the reason and the date of return must be reviewed together.

Do I lose claims if I hand the car back?

Merely returning the car does not in principle amount to a waiver of claims. Record a reservation of rights and review any additional statements in the handover record.

Are the leasing instalments automatically my responsibility until the end of the contract?

No. Passing on the remaining leasing instalments across the board despite the return of the vehicle is legally problematic. An own contribution and special vehicle requests call for a separate review of the contract.

Legal basis and sources

As of: 15 November 2026. General legal information; the specific agreements, documents and time limits are what matter.

Next step

I advise employees, executives and employers in Munich and nationwide. When you get in touch, briefly describe your matter and mention any time limits that are running. We agree the scope of work and fees before you instruct me.

Request an introductory call