Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Working time law

Exceeding the 48-hour working week: when can employees claim damages?

The EU Working Time Directive provides for an average maximum working time of 48 hours per seven-day period, including overtime.

Read the German original

A wall clock, wristwatch and standing calendar side by side.
This image is AI-generated.

On-call duty, maximum working time and compensation are legally related, but they are not the same thing. In October 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union explained the conditions for State liability for working time rules that breach EU law, and why it matters whether the claimant actually suffered damage.

How does the European 48-hour limit work?

Article 6(b) of the Working Time Directive 2003/88/EC requires that the average working time per seven-day period, including overtime, does not exceed 48 hours. The calculation must take into account the working time relevant under EU law, including on-call duty where it has to be included. In German law, the Working Time Act (Arbeitszeitgesetz) and special rules in particular set requirements for permissible working time.

Someone who is supposedly only performing “on-call duty” may nevertheless be working for the purposes of working time law. The legal classification must be kept separate from the question of pay.

What did the CJEU decide in Case C-808/24?

On 8 October 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on a claim against a Member State whose rules did not count all on-call duty as working time. According to the judgment, the definition of working time in Article 2(1) of the Directive does not, on its own, give rise to a separate right to damages under EU law. A claim for damages for breach of the 48-hour limit requires that the applicable conditions for State liability are met. (CJEU ruled on 8 October 2026)

Where a State is obliged to pay compensation, non-material damage may not be assessed schematically on the basis of the duration of the breach of EU law alone. The damage actually suffered and causally attributable to the breach must be taken into account, in compliance with the principles of effectiveness and equivalence.

Do employees automatically get paid for overtime?

No. The finding of a working time breach is not the same as a claim for pay or a claim for damages, or as the amount of either. The CJEU case specifically concerns State liability for a national rule that is contrary to EU law. Against private employers, the contractual, collective agreement and national legal bases must be examined separately.

For companies, the decision may be a reason to have on-call time, time recording models and rest periods legally reviewed.

What should employers and employees document?

  • Regular working time and overtime actually worked.
  • Start, duration and arrangement of on-call duty.
  • Relevant balancing and reference periods.
  • Health or other concrete consequences of possible breaches.
  • Contractual and national legal bases for possible claims for pay and compensation.

For employers, a legal review of working time models makes sense; in the event of specific disputes, the employment law advice in Munich can help. (Employment Law Advice in Munich)

Frequently asked questions

Is every week with more than 48 hours of work prohibited?

What matters is the average working time calculated under the applicable rules and the permitted reference period; other national limits may also apply.

Is there a flat fee per hour of overtime?

No general flat-rate damages per hour can be derived from the CJEU judgment. The legal basis, the damage and causation must be examined separately.

If you have any questions, please contact Kanzlei Osuji or call +49 174 343 0142.

As of 6 November 2026. Author: Noah Osuji, lawyer. General legal information, no individual consultation. AI-generated symbol image without real participants.

Next step

We agree the scope of work and fees before you instruct me.