Employment law and pay
Equal pay: when are employees entitled to the same salary?
A claim to equal pay can exist where a person is paid less than others for equal or equivalent work because of their sex. A better-paid comparator of the other sex can be enough to presume such discrimination. Whether back pay is actually owed depends in particular on whether the work is comparable and on the reasons for the pay difference.

What does equal pay mean in an employment relationship?
In the context of pay equality between the sexes, equal pay means that a person’s sex must not influence the pay for equal or equivalent work. The basis is, in particular, Article 157 TFEU and sections 3 and 7 of the Remuneration Transparency Act (EntgTranspG). The protection is not limited to women. A man can also be disadvantaged compared with a better-paid woman.
Not every pay difference is therefore unlawful. Different duties, relevant experience or genuinely performance-related criteria can explain a difference. What matters is whether an objective reason supports the specific pay decision. The mere fact that contracts were negotiated individually is not automatically sufficient.
This article concerns pay equality between the sexes. Separate equal pay rules also apply to the equal treatment of temporary agency workers.
Same job title, same work?
An identical job title makes it easier to get one’s bearings, but it does not decide the case. Two employees can hold the same title and have duties of very different scope. Conversely, roles with different titles can be equivalent.
The assessment turns on the actual requirements: What knowledge is needed? What responsibility does the role carry? What burdens and working conditions come with it? The assessment should cover the role as a whole and not pick out individual prestigious tasks.
For a first comparison, job descriptions, organisational responsibilities and the period under review are therefore more informative than the business card. For part-time work, the working hours and pay must be put on a comparable basis.
Is a single better-paid colleague enough?
Yes, such a comparison can be sufficient. The Federal Labour Court (BAG) confirmed this in its judgment of 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24. The size of a comparison group does not rule out a pairwise comparison. This does not, however, mean that a payment claim is automatically established: the conditions of the comparison must be set out and, if disputed, proved; the employer can rebut the presumption by showing suitable facts.
The article on pairwise comparison and top salaries explains why the median is not a general upper limit for a claim and why the highest salary is nevertheless not simply owed.
Which pay counts?
The review should not stop at the monthly basic salary. Depending on how they are structured, variable pay, employment-related share programmes and occupational pension benefits can be included. The individual components and their conditions must be kept apart. A disadvantage in one pay component does not become lawful simply because another component is higher; the requirement of equal pay applies, in principle, to each individual building block.
A bonus that is a percentage of basic salary can carry forward a difference that arose there. Another bonus may instead depend on separate performance targets. The article Equal pay for bonuses, equity compensation and company pensions explains this in more detail.
How can a suspicion be checked in an orderly way?
A sensible first step is an overview of your own pay and the duties you actually perform. This includes your employment contract, pay changes, payslips, bonus terms and any available information on the comparator role. Do not obtain other people’s personnel records on your own initiative.
A right to information can help close information gaps. The statutory right to information and the claim to equal pay are, however, different rights with different conditions. In particular, the substantive prohibition of discrimination does not depend on whether the establishment size required for a particular right to information is met. Details are in our existing article on the right to information on pay transparency.
The European framework is explained in the article on the EU Pay Transparency Directive.
Time also plays a role: claims for pay, damages and compensation must be distinguished legally. Limitation and possible cut-off periods must be checked for each claim. The two-month deadline for asserting a claim under section 15(4) of the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) should not be equated across the board with the time limits for all pay differences.
Frequently asked questions
Must an employer pay all employees the same amount? No. Equal pay prohibits sex-based disadvantage for equal or equivalent work. Objectively justified differences remain possible.
Does the protection also apply in small establishments? The requirement of equal pay is not limited to establishments above the threshold for the individual right to information.
Is lower pay already proof of discrimination? Not in itself. Among other things, the comparator, whether the work is equal or equivalent and possible objective explanations are decisive.
For an assessment of an individual case, you can request employment law advice. Employers will find a structured starting point in the pay analysis for companies.
Your next step
First draw up an overview of duties, pay components and periods. Note which comparison information is reliably available. Have possible deadlines checked before you wait solely for further information.
Legal bases: Article 157 TFEU, Remuneration Transparency Act (EntgTranspG), section 22 AGG, BAG, 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24.
As of: 14 November 2026. General legal information; the assessment of an individual case depends on its specific circumstances.
