Employment law and pay
Equal pay: why bonuses, equity and company pensions must be reviewed
A sex-based pay difference can affect several components of the pay package. Besides base salary, bonuses, work-related equity compensation and company pension benefits may be relevant. The review must take account of the conditions of each individual component.

Why comparing salaries alone is not enough
Pay systems often combine several calculation variables. A lower base salary can affect the amount of a bonus calculated as a percentage. If both amounts feed into a pension formula, the difference can take effect there again.
Other benefits arise under their own rules. In an equity programme, grant, performance period, vesting, exercise and payout can occur at different times. It would therefore be too crude simply to compare the year-end total on the payslip. The principle of equal pay applies to each individual pay component; a blanket offset between different components is not sufficient (BAG, 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24, para. 21).
The BAG proceedings 8 AZR 300/24 concerned several pay components. This shows the importance of a differentiated review, but does not give rise to a blanket entitlement to every equity grant sought. For the outcome of the proceedings, see pairwise comparison and top salary.
Worked example: when the bonus depends on base salary
A simplified, entirely fictitious example: annual base salary is EUR 72,000 instead of EUR 80,000, and the bonus is ten per cent of it in each case. Arithmetically, this produces a EUR 8,000 difference in base salary and a further EUR 800 in the bonus. This calculation only shows how the formula works. Whether the total of EUR 8,800 has to be paid retrospectively depends on the legal requirements, the comparison period and the bonus conditions.
How to break down the pay package
| Component | Key question | Typical documents |
|---|---|---|
| Base salary | Which amount applies for which scope of work and period? | Contract, pay adjustment letters, payslips |
| Bonus | Which targets, factors and bases of calculation determine the entitlement? | Bonus plan, target agreement, target assessment |
| Equity-based compensation | Who owes which rights and when do they arise? | Plan terms, grant letters, vesting and exercise documents |
| Company pension | Which factors determine contributions or accrued entitlements? | Pension scheme rules, calculations, commitments |
The table is a practical aid to organising the review. It does not replace the question of whether the benefit in the specific model falls within the employment-law concept of pay and who the defendant is.
Can different performance explain a different bonus?
In principle, genuinely different performance can be relevant. What matters, however, is whether performance determines the bonus in question under the applicable conditions and whether the criteria were applied in a way that can be followed.
A company-success bonus follows different rules from a personal sales premium. If both are treated under the collective term “bonus”, important differences can be lost. In the assessment, too, it must be clear whether personal targets, team targets or company metrics are decisive.
A later statement that the higher-paid person was generally more valuable does not answer these questions. The organisational side is covered in the pay analysis for employers.
Particular points on equity programmes
With RSUs, options or virtual shares, the party under the obligation must be established first. A claim against the employer does not follow merely because a group programme is connected with the employment relationship. What matters are the specific commitments and the companies involved.
In addition, grant values and actual payouts should not simply be equated. Different grant dates and programme conditions can affect the comparison. On the question of who the defendant is, the existing article RSUs or VSOPs from a foreign parent complements the review.
What applies on separation from the employer?
Outstanding pay claims should be clarified before a settlement clause is agreed. Severance does not automatically answer whether bonus claims, pay differences or rights under equity programmes still exist.
In practice, it is advisable to draw up a list by claim, period, due date and obligor. The article on bonus, RSUs and VSOPs in a termination agreement deals with this interface.
Frequently asked questions
Is an equal base salary enough? No. Possible disadvantage can lie in other pay components.
Must the employer always make good equity programmes? No. The legal basis, programme terms and defendant must be examined separately.
Does a correction of base salary automatically increase the company pension? That depends on the pension scheme rules and the relevant calculation factors.
For orientation, see the equal pay overview. For complex pay packages, advice for executives is available.
Your next step
Besides payslips, collect bonus plans, grant letters and pension terms. For each component, note who owes it and when it falls due.
Sources: Article 157 TFEU, section 5 of the Remuneration Transparency Act (EntgTranspG), BAG, 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24.
As of: 14 November 2026. General legal information; the assessment of an individual case depends on its specific circumstances.
