Kanzlei OsujiLaw firm
Munich

Employment law and pay

Equal pay by pairwise comparison: must the employer pay the highest salary?

An equal pay claim can rest on a single better-paid person of the other sex. If the employer cannot rebut the presumption of sex-based disadvantage for the same or equivalent work, that comparator’s pay can be the relevant benchmark – including above the median. There is, however, no general entitlement to the highest salary in the company.

Two envelopes on plinths of different heights with a magnifying glass in front.
This image is AI-generated.

What did the Federal Labour Court decide?

In its judgment of 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24 – the Federal Labour Court (BAG) confirmed pairwise comparison as a basis for an equal pay claim. An employee does not have to accept a group figure merely because several possible comparators exist.

However, the court did not finally award the claim in full. It set aside the lower court’s decision in part and remitted the case to that extent. It would therefore be incorrect to say that the BAG has already ordered pay to be brought fully into line with the top salary.

The general legal starting point is set out in the overview of equal pay.

Why the median does not cap the claim

The median is the middle value of a distribution ordered by amount. It can be relevant within the statutory rights to information. However, such a statistical value does not conclusively answer whether there is unjustified disadvantage in relation to a specific comparator.

A salary above the median can therefore also be legally relevant. Choosing a highly paid person does not, however, replace an examination of that person’s work. Naming the same hierarchy level or the same job title does not by itself resolve every factual question about equivalence.

Information and payment claims remain separate. The article on pay information explains the information side.

Who has to set out and prove what?

The starting point is lower pay than a person of the other sex for the same or equivalent work. The claimant must set out and, where necessary, prove the facts required for this. A mere assumption that someone earns more does not replace that basis.

Once the relevant comparison facts are established, the presumption of sex-based disadvantage under section 22 of the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) generally applies. The requirements for this presumption of causation may not be tightened by an additional demand for a preponderance of probability. The employer must then set out and prove that the principle of equal treatment was not breached.

Which explanation can justify the difference?

Different responsibility or relevant qualifications can matter. The quality of the work can also play a role. For executives, leadership performance that has been assessed in a transparent way may therefore come into consideration.

Blanket judgements such as “more convincing in presentation” or “stronger performer overall”, however, do not yet explain why a particular pay component differs by a particular amount. What is needed is a verifiable link between the alleged criterion and the actual pay decision.

In its judgment of 16 February 2023 – 8 AZR 450/21 – the BAG had already made clear that higher pay agreed individually does not, by itself, rebut the presumption of discrimination. This does not mean that individual contract negotiations are prohibited. It means that their outcome must additionally be measured against the equal pay requirement.

What follows for employees and companies?

Employees should set out the work, the period and the pay components side by side in an orderly way. Companies should check whether the grounds for differentiation actually applied can be evidenced for the period concerned. An assessment system designed after the event does not replace facts about the salary decision made at the time.

A formally deficient pay system does not automatically lead to losing the case. Conversely, a properly described system offers no protection if actual decision-making practice departs from it. How this review can be organised is shown in the checklist for a pay analysis.

Frequently asked questions

Can the best-paid person be the comparator? Yes, provided the legal conditions for comparison are met. A high salary alone neither makes that person unsuitable nor automatically the binding benchmark.

Has equal pay only become enforceable since 2025? No. The decision continues existing EU and national principles; earlier BAG judgments had already dealt with comparison with individual employees.

What needs to be reviewed where there are several pay components? The conditions of the claim and the grounds of justification must be examined for each component. More on this under bonuses and equity compensation.

If your pay or a pay decision in your company is affected, you can request a review.

Your next step

Describe the two roles and the respective scope of work for the same period. Assign the pay difference to a specific component. This makes it possible to assess whether the pairwise comparison holds up legally.

Case law: BAG, 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24, in particular on pairwise comparison, the presumption of causation and rebuttal; BAG, 16 February 2023 – 8 AZR 450/21, in particular on individually negotiated pay.

As of: 14 November 2026. General legal information; the assessment of an individual case depends on its specific circumstances.