Employment law and pay
Equal pay check for employers: reviewing pay gaps in a traceable way
A reliable pay analysis links figures to the actual requirements of the work. It shows where differences exist, which reasons explain them and where action is still needed. A statistically small gender pay gap alone does not prove that every individual pay decision is free of discrimination.

The requirements of the claim are explained in the equal pay overview.
1. Define the scope of the review
Before the evaluation, it should be clear which employer, which employees and which periods are being examined. Group-wide overviews can be useful; however, they do not automatically answer who is responsible for a specific pay decision or who owes a benefit.
Capturing pay in full is equally important. Besides base salary, the stocktake should include the relevant allowances, bonus schemes, benefits in kind and pension components. For equity programmes, commitments and responsibilities must be clarified separately. The article on equal pay and variable compensation provides guidance.
2. Compare roles on an appropriate basis
A usable job evaluation starts with the actual duties. Knowledge, responsibility, burdens and working conditions should be described using uniform criteria. In doing so, roles that have traditionally been filled by different groups must not be valued differently from the outset through the choice of criteria.
Job titles, pay bands and hierarchy levels are helpful ordering features. They do not replace an analysis of the work. Anyone who forms comparator groups only on the basis of existing salaries can unknowingly carry the very inequality under review into the review model.
3. Explain anomalies, do not only calculate them
A calculated deviation is first of all a signal for review. To classify it, the objective reasons must be linked to the specific decision. Which additional qualification was needed? What additional responsibility arose? Which performance was assessed against which standard?
The documentation should show at least the pay component concerned, the time of the decision, the criterion applied and the underlying facts. Keywords such as “market”, “potential” or “negotiation” without further facts are not a reliable explanation.
The pairwise comparison under the BAG shows why specific individual comparisons remain important in addition to group analysis.
4. Involve the works council and data protection
Pay analyses process sensitive employee information. Access, purpose, retention and the sharing of results must be defined. The fact that an evaluation serves pay equality does not permit every publication of individual salaries.
Where a works council exists, its statutory rights to information and co-determination must be checked. In particular, questions of pay structure and pay principles may fall under section 87(1) no. 10 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). This does not make every individual salary level itself subject to co-determination. The legal classification must fit the specific project.
5. Turn the analysis into a lasting process
A one-off report quickly loses value if hiring, promotions and pay rounds are subsequently carried out on different standards. The organisation should therefore determine who reviews deviations, which documents are required and when a new evaluation takes place.
| Occasion | Practical review step |
|---|---|
| Hiring | Document the grading and the reasons for the position within the pay band |
| Pay round | Apply criteria uniformly and review conspicuous deviations |
| Promotion | Distinguish new duties from mere changes of title |
| Request for information | Clarify responsibility, legal basis and data access |
| Disadvantage identified | Assess correction and possible retrospective claims separately |
Preparation for European transparency obligations can build on this process. In doing so, it is essential to keep separate which obligations already apply and which depend on implementation.
Frequently asked questions
Does a pay band prove pay equality? No. What also matters is how employees are graded within the band and how pay adjustments are actually made.
Is every unexplained difference unlawful? No. It first calls for an objective review. If required grounds of justification remain unproven in a dispute, however, the consequences can be significant.
Do companies with fewer than 200 employees not have to do anything? The substantive prohibition of sex-based pay disadvantage applies irrespective of the threshold for the special right to information.
Our employment law advice for employers supports the legal structuring of pay systems and the review of specific anomalies.
Your next step
Name a responsible function, set the review period and record the pay criteria actually applied. Clarify data access and co-determination rights before individual salaries are evaluated or shared.
Sources: section 4 of the Remuneration Transparency Act (EntgTranspG), sections 17–18 EntgTranspG, section 87 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), BAG, 23 October 2025 – 8 AZR 300/24.
As of: 14 November 2026. General legal information; the assessment of an individual case depends on its specific circumstances.
